 potterinu 2009-09-28 . chapter 1to much obsessing over ginny for my taste |
 Miz636 2009-09-12 . chapter 37This story... Has been as amazing as the other two I read. I can't believe how much of the books you got right! I mean, it was so amazing to read this and see all the stuff that was the same as the final Harry Potter book.
It's sad to have to be done because now I can't enjoy anymore of your stories written like this... Ah well. I'll probably come back and reread them because they were so good!
Like I said last time, please write more stories. The ones I've read were all so good! |
 RemmyKif 2009-08-18 . chapter 37Hello Mel. I know you wrote this story quite some rme ago but i thought I still ought to review. Firstly, I am a huge fan of PoE and CotD - have read both about five times now. I delayed reading this for about a year now because, having done a quick check, couldn't bear to read Remus die (he's my favourite character). I eventually caved in. I spend most of my free time computer programming and love a good drama on tv or book /fanfic to read to unwind a bit. This turned out to be a brilliant read and I want to thank you for your hard work - I really am gratefull. A wonderfull peace of writing that (although I'd never admit it in real lfe) almost had me in tears at times. Your writing is more mature and confident from when you began in PoE. Do you still write? I'd love to read more stories written by you. If you do write something will it go on your website? Whatever you ate or will do, thank you and good luck with your endeavours. Pip pip! |
 Shadows-of-Realm 2009-08-12 . chapter 37AMAZING STORY! PLEASE DO A SEQUEL! |
 142staircases 2009-07-25 . chapter 37Hi,
This was amazing.
You must have had about 12 heart attacks reading Deathly Hallows. I had heart attacks reading this realizing it was written before book 7. Excellent work. |
 moonlit severus 2009-06-03 . chapter 37Hi, just finished reading this, took me ages but it was brilliant the whole way through! Great job! |
 Karl Skywalker 2009-05-24 . chapter 37Excellent story!
To me, this story is much more satisfying than the seventh book. Especially in realm of relationship between Harry and Ginny. They are my favorite couple. I wish that this story is canon. Good job :D
It looks like we have a new Dark Lord in Dudley... Or is that red herring?
Keep up with good work! |
 s-david-m 2009-03-16 . chapter 14A very good story, and a plausible AU. Thanks! :-) |
 bookivore 2009-03-09 . chapter 2That was the best Dursley lecture I've read! And I love how Hermione tries to get herself arrested. |
 Fire Fan 2009-02-24 . chapter 37I'm really really hoping you write a sequal. |
 jwatson16202 2009-02-08 . chapter 1i know this story was written a long time ago, but it remains possibly my favourite fanfic ever. i read this before i was even aware of the world of fanfiction. my friend sent me this believing it to be the "leaked" 7th book, clearly that wasn't the case, i did however sit up all night reading it when i should have been sleeping preparing for a flight to denmark the next morning. i just couldnt stop.
i absolutely love this story, i think you have written the characters really well, and you are obviously very good at writing emotional moments. i was (almost) a blubbering wreck at the scene at the end where he meets his parents.
a very good job :)
James |
 blackice552 2009-02-05 . chapter 1This story was awesome. I think I like it even better than Deathly Hallows. I love how you developed the Harry/Ginny relationship so much. |
 Ciroth 2009-01-04 . chapter 37Great fic. Plan on writing something on Didders the Dork Lord? |
 alwaysNaruHina 2008-12-11 . chapter 37Your story is amazing as always. No wonder if I'll be waiting your next long story eagerly. Well done! |
 nia-ox 2008-11-01 . chapter 37Phew- I finished it! I know you wrote this a long time ago, but I just thought I'd tell you how much I loved it. It's fantastic! The amount of pain, action, heartache...but the best was the triumph.
I had a good laugh about the Dursleys dying by Dudley's hand. I can imagine the prophecy now: "The one with the power to vanquish the um, new Dark Lord has er, already been born...born to he who lived in the Dark Lord's cupboard and vanquished the other Dark Lord by sending a Golden Snitch through the Veil...Um, neither can live while the other survives and all that crap..." xD
I hope you find time to write a sequel - I'd love to read it! |