 Michi P. 2009-09-04 . chapter 29You make me forget that your story isn't really what happened for Jack and Ennis. It's just so, so perfect that I can't imagine them any other way. I went to TJ Maxx today, just shopping around, and I happened to see a DVD disply. I took a look, and what do you think I saw there? Brokeback Mountain, just sitting there, and all of a sudden it hit me like a brick that JACK IS NOT ALIVE.
Let me tell you, I almost cried. I've only seen the movie once, and I liked it ok, and I found the prequel to this story through someone's favorites and decided to give it a read. It was the first Brokeback Mountain fanfiction I'd ever read, and you sure set the bar high. I don't know if I'm going to be able to find anything of this caliber, I really don't.
So now I'm going to rant about the other story while I'm here, since I wasn't coherent enough earlier today to do so. I was thinking about Liz, and all of a sudden I also remembered that she didn't actually exist in the movie. And what did that make her? An OC. But see, I almost can't think of her like that because you WROTE HER SO WELL that she just kind of...blended into the story. Like she was supposed to be there the entire time, even for the actual movie. I couldn't understand how you created such an in depth person, involved her in the plot just enough to confirm that she was important, yet keep her character so subtle that it was hardly noticeable that she was completely original. Frankly, it's amazing, and you've got a talent for writing that a lot of people would be jealous for.
And gosh darnit, I love Junior. She's so...real. And understanding. And helpful. Honestly, she's so awesome I wish I were her friend in real life.
And don't get me started on Jack and Ennis. There are no words to describe how much I love the both of them AND their relationship in this story. Once again, I find it hard to believe that you fabricated EVERYTHING because it was so well written. I forgot, when I started reading this, that Jack Twist was beat down and killed, and that he and Ennis never got their happily evere after. Not like in this story. It amazes me their love for each other, and how well you portray it in their characters and in your style.
I will also make a comment as to how great it is you've stuck to each character's diction. You chose to write Jack and Ennis' distinct accents (and again, this is my first Brokeback Mountain fanfiction so I'm not sure if every author writes their accent or not), yet you still pay attention to the fact that the people around them are of the New England persuasion and don't speak like that. Or they like them.
So in short: 1. I admire your writing more than I could ever tell you. 2. I really don't want this story to end, because I'm pretty sure I will have a depressing week once this story is finished up. 3. I LOVE ENNIS AND JACK you wrote them to be my heroes. 4. I LOVE THIS STORY SO MUCH. If you couldn't already tell.
So, this is the longest review I've written in my LIFE and I'm pretty sure I will never write another quite as long as this. If this were Facebook, I'd like this story at least 1236987162374619234 times. So.
Thanks so much for making my day, my month, my year. This story will forever be in my mind. I can't wait to read the rest of it. Good luck writing!
~Michi P. |
 Marifw 2008-11-15 . chapter 27Wow! I really love this story! I see it's been a while since you wrote it, will you finish it? I sure hope so. I want to know what's happening on the farm with Lizzie, and how Jack and Ennis will react to that, and how they will manage another week appart, and if Francie will come around in the end. Please, please, please update! |
 Winterhug 2008-05-01 . chapter 8Just a comment about this line:
"She'd never seen Ennis kiss no one else, let alone a man, and she'd never been this close to two men kissing before, so it was doubly disconcerting."
Perhaps this statement will be explained later... but Alma saw Jack and him passionately kissing on the steps to the apartment. Right? |