I really don't know what to say... :D

... I think I might actually be speechless. It was funny... but... it... Huh. I suppose all I can say is "What the hell?"

I am completely speechless. It's perfect in every way.

Do you know any scary Toms?

Delay?

Bwahahaha!

I've never been much of a Colbert fan, but he couldn't have been more perfect for this crossover!

Totally laughed out loud at Hermione's "Big Book of Insanely Complicated Spells." Yeah.

Well-constructed and *very* clever. I suspect even Stephen himself would be impressed.

This was ultimately amazing.
xD
Whoodathunkit?
(0_o Ignore that last word/sentence/thing)
xD anyway. this is really good.

A wag of the finger for writing a fanfic so full of win and awesome that I was blown off my seat.

Funny as hell.

He's funny, admittedly insane, but damn funny. : )

Blinking epic!!
You really know your Colbert AND Harry Potter. It was hilarious.

Ohmigosh. HILARIOUS. I was cracking up.

BEST. EVER. I seriously don't know how this didn't come to my attention early. I flipping love Stephen Colbert and Harry Potter more than anything and to have them together is...amazing. Absolutely brilliant. Very nice Word, fantastic ending line. Love love love.

Great fanfic, or GREATEST fanfic?

I got this link from TV Tropes. I don't traverse the murky depths of the Harry Potter fandom much, for the same reason I can't read A Series of Unfortunate Events fanfics. (That was definitely my favourite section. Why can't people be happy with Quigley/Violet? Klaus/Whatsername?) Anyway, compared to most of the other ** I've seen, this is definitely the best. I'll leave it up to youy to decide if that's a good thing or not. Wait, scratch that, this is the best AFTER My Immortal. The lulz in that one are insurmountable. But bugbears! What could be more terrifying! :-O
I did notice some random OOC-ness (how can Colbert NOT be narcissistic?) and I found the interview portion quite lacking, but that's always been my least favourite part of the show anyway.
Overall this was really funny and well written, which is quite rare for a crack fic, especially one this outlandish.

Oh, and I know I shouldn't ask, but Mirror, Blackbeak, Sockporn, Love at the Lake? You know I'm going to have to google those now and then gouge my eyes out, don't you?

Great job capturing the essence of Colbert. Loved it.

OMFG!! I JUST HAD LIKE THE BIGGEST FANGASM OF MY ENTIRE LIFE! THE WORD WAS AWESOME AND AFTER THAT I WAS LIKE "IT WOULD BE EVEN BETTER IF THERE WAS THREAT-DOWN". AND THEN THERE WAS!! BUGBEARS!!IT WAS PERFECT!! U EVEN MADE HIM AN EAGLE!! HE WAS THE FARTHERIST THING FROM OOC!AND THE FINAL LINE AT THE END WAS COMPLETELY AWESOME! "All right, then. One final question. Albus Dumbledore. Great Headmaster? Or...the greatest Headmaster?"
THAT WAS ** BRILLANT!! ALMOST AS IF IT WERE ACTUALLY TRUE!! AND IT WOULD OBVIOUSLY KICK ** AWESOME IF IT WAS!!
FINAL WORDS: LOVED IT. LOVED IT.LOVED IT. U R TOTALLY AWESOME!!*TIP OF THE HAT* AND LOVE STEPHEN COLBERT!XDXDXDXDXDXDXD