Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Watch Over Me - Reviews: Page 1 of 4

sta2l1ght
2008-06-21
ch 4,
abuseIt was so great!! hm..I like romance sories and this story sounds like Lucy is the main character so I wish for her to have some romance like let the pairing be Peter and Lucy,, Edmund and Lucy and others Let there be a little jealousy and stuff but always let there be a happy ending^ ^
thx!
pinki84297
2008-05-31
ch 4,
abusehow old were they all in this story? it was sehr gut though (:
JaBoyYa
2008-05-26
ch 4,
abusenice very interesting
Sairalinde Inwe
2008-01-26
ch 4,
abuseAw...Peter really was a git, but he definately made up for it in this chapter. I don't know what I would do if I had to see one of my brothers ride off into battle and they said I couldn't come with them. You really showed how much Peter really cares for Lucy, I liked that. I also really liked Edmund in this story. He was the one who really beat some sense into Peter and supported Lucy as well. This was an amazing stoy, great work!
Kelev
2007-10-25
ch 4,
abuseThis was nice, I like the reaction of Edmund's being in complete contrast to Susan's, though I think Peter's anger level was a bit out of character, as it is hard for me to picture him so mad he wanted to punch Edmund for defending Lucy's side of the story.
floppyearsthebunny
2007-06-13
ch 4,
abuseI love it
Andi Horton
2007-04-10
ch 4,
abuseI think I need to give myself a swift kick to some soft part or other ... I never realised how many of your fics I had unintentionally not kept up with reviews. It makes no sense to me because I have you on author alert and I'm sure if I saw your name in my inbox I'd click on it right away. If I were not so mad at myself I'd devote even more time to fuming over this. Instead I am just going to review :P

As ever, your writing is lovely, and I have no quibbles with your form at all. I love the touch of Peter's gift to Lucy; it's an acknowledgment of her desires and his concession to them, bless his dear, protective heart. Even when you want to strangle him you just can't help wanting to kiss him, can you?! :P You capture that so perfectly; even when he's being awkward, he somehow still managed to be Peter, and I can't put my finger on how you get that across, but you do, and I adore it.

Again, the whole author alert thing ... I dunno what's up with that. I don't even know who to ask to look into it. But meantime, know that I do love this and am so happy that I did wander back and find out what a dolt I'd been to miss it :P
Hannah
2007-03-19
ch 4, anon.
abusei really, really loved this story. i have read all the chronicles of narnia approximately a million times, and lucy and peter have always been my favorites, although i really like the edmund you portrayed here. you're true to the books without being limited by them.

i think you're right about the ending needing work...not sure how you'd go about adding to it, though. it just seemed a little abrupt after the smooth flow of the rest of the story. perhaps you could insert a few lines between them cuddling and lucy not being able to bear losing peter.

overall, a lovely story. thanks for writing it.
floppyearsthebunny
2007-03-19
ch 1,
abusei like this story, but I am wondering why Peter is so angry and rough? Yes He is overprotective, but I never thought he would be that rough and mean. but then I not an expert or close on criticizeing it's just my oppinion.
lightsabermaster
2006-09-28
ch 4,
abuseAww. Such a sweet story. :)

It's on the favorites!
Houtori
2006-07-25
ch 4,
abuseWow... that was absolutely brillant! Thank you so much, 'cause this is the first Narnia fic that I have ever read, and it's such a great 'first-thing'! Keep on writing!
Kelsey Estel the TolkieNarn...
2006-06-05
ch 4,
abuseThis was great! I love the ending, its so sweet! I think it fits well, but I wouldn't mind another chapter.

I love moments between Peter and Lucy! They have so few. Its either Peter and Edmund, or Susan, or all of them, but never Lucy alone.

great, Francie!

KelsE
Lady Eivel
2006-05-26
ch 4,
abuseAny good? It's brilliant! Loved it, and I've gone pretty damp-eyed now. Keep it up!
Stormythomas
2006-05-25
ch 4,
abuseI think it's fine the way it is, though I do see what you mean about it needing more. I would be okay leaving it as is, but it's up to you.

Anyways this story was amazing. I loved it. Especially this chapter it was so cute and sweet.
frangipanigirl
2006-05-24
ch 4, anon.
abuseThis was a great story. I have been reading it since I first noticed that you had posted, and I have loved reading it. You had me worried about Peter's treatment of Lucy, but you made it all right in the end. I loved this story. Keep up your good work!
Return to Top