Awesome job! i can't wait to see what'll happen next, and i think you should leave Hogai alive ^^

Don't kill hogai! Have him go report to the hokage... :D or something like that.

Excelent Story so far! I don't think Kakashi should leave him alive.

~waits patently for an update~

Hey, I really like your story so far, as well as your other fanfics that I've read. I heard that something happened that made you reluctant to continue writing this pairing, and though I don't know what it is, I really think you should continue. Your a wonderful author and your stories are great. So please continue writing, you really have talent. And for your question at the end of the chapter, I think you should kill him. Since Kakashi isn't really himself at the moment he really wouldn't fight Itachi much about his decisions (i.e. him killing enemy nin's to practice his sharigan), and like you said Itachi definitly wouldn't make the mistake of letting him live. Plus, it would make the realization of what happened to Kakashi that much greater for Naruto, Sasuke, Sakura, and Iruka if Konoha is still ignorant to what happened.
Faith

when will you put up chapter 6 i really would like to see how kakashi ends up

wow... I really like this story! plz update soon, cant wait to find out what happens...

Great chapter! I think you should let him live so he can tell the others what happened!! Keep up the amazing work and update soon please!! ^_^

i say kill him off, oh, and are you planning on continueing this? it seems really good, but there hasn't been an update for ages!!

leave him alive it will make the story more intense

hey there! how come no updates til now?! hope ya update soon, the plot is great & it feels sad if it weren't gonna be done tho... hope to hear from ya soon! ja ne!

ohh this is so interesting!! please, continue it!!

I say he should be alive and that way he could go back to kohona and warn everyone of kakashi and stuff, but that's only an opinon. Anyway, this story is awesome update soon.

It's been so long since your last update...I really hope you'll continue this story, because it's really great :) The pairing of ItaKaka grew on me after I read this.
In chapter 4 you mentioned Kakashi practicing summonings...but if he summoned Pakkun, won't the dog tell him the truth?

Let him live. We may end up regretting it now, but you can do so much with a living character than if he dies. Plus Kakashi's not in his right state of mind if you know what I mean. update soon!

I review!!
So you better update!!
Plz!