Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: For the Best
Nyxelestia 2006-11-01 . chapter 1
LOVE IT!
You should write one of your depressing stories, but with Dumbledore's death.
Phoenix80hp 2006-10-19 . chapter 1
wow really sad but good! I like it!
Shimbaun 2006-05-08 . chapter 1
Yeah. This is good. I think if too much was after Albus's death it would spoil it.
Dracan Hastur 2006-05-04 . chapter 1
Nice fic.
I like this reflecting and thoughtful Harry.
I also had the idea that Harry might be the last horcrux and that he could die himself if he kills Voldemort.

I did´t like Dumbledores death in Book 6, so I´m glad that you´re acknowleding it in this fic only.
court2010 2006-04-27 . chapter 1
Oh my gosh! That story made my eyes water! It was AMAZING!
Phoenix.G.Fawkes 2006-04-24 . chapter 1
I think you had a great insight into Hermione's and Ron's thoughts regarding their parents and honesty, and your description of Harry's changes was very well-done. I think you've just captured the moment he stops being a child to become a man perfectly.
Just one little thing: if they're at the Welcome Feast, Harry should be seventeen, not sixteen.
Angela 2006-04-24 . chapter 1
I liked this piece. My favorite part is how you document Harry's journey through Hogwarts so simply, with him coming to the conclusion that it was all "for the best", and tying it in with the impending war and his possiblt demise. I would love to see a companion piece, or a sequel, after the 7th book, talking about how Harry was better off not knowing ahead of time what awaited him - especially if Harry dies. I think it would be funny, in that sad, depressing sort of way, but also a good closure for him as well.
Return to Top