Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: A Certain Redhead - Reviews: Page 1 of 10
southie 2008-11-05 . chapter 15
Hm.. So why's there so many C/K fics which actually makes u like S/K? I'm just confused. And u know, S/K is so totally lame.. Err that is, uh, used to be. Damn it. So I'm off to find some Stan/Kyle goodness..

Thanks for the fic :)
microwaved noodles 2008-07-15 . chapter 15
Oh gawd. I'm not used to reading fanfics with sad endings, it seems, because whenever I do, I end up bawling my eyes out. D:
animeroxz 2008-07-12 . chapter 15
I loved it. Very sweet and dramatic story. I felt bad for Kyle around the middle of the story but things got better and I'm glad for that! Glad that bitch Samantha got what's coming to her but Kyle is too sweet he should have let them continue to humiliate her. Didn't see the whole Stan/Kyle think happening but I wasn't suprised when it happened. Too bad Eric and Kyle didn't get together at the end but it was too be expected. Anyways loved your story and I love how I you kept Cartman in character through out the entire story! You're an awesome writer of fiction!
PrettyLilJewGirl 2008-06-24 . chapter 15
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW!
Seriously! Omigod that was AMAZING! You're so descriptive... damn. And wow, I didn't see the StanxKyle coming, but I LOVED it. You've written it so perfectly... not over the top, but still there.
And the way you wrote Eric? Sheer genius. I was not expecting the sad (?) ending, but somehow it left me with this really strong feeling. Not depression- this fic didn't depress me, wonder of wonders- but it made me think.
...Am I even making sense?
Anyway. So this fic was brilliant. I never thought there could be so many different metaphors for a person's features, lol. :D This is so totally faved. And so are YOU. *faves story* *faves author*
Taboo Love 2008-06-22 . chapter 15
-cries- I just finished you fic. And one word to describe the last chapter 'heart-wrenching'.

I cried.

I felt that the emotion that Cartman felt towards Kyle was truly genuine, but sadly unrequited. I can't help but feel sort of angry at Kyle for not liking him back.

That's life, and why this is a great fic because it is not sugar-coated because sometimes the greats stories are those that do not have 'happy'-endings, so to speak.

Beautifully written and I hope to read more of your Cartman x Kyle fics in the near future *V*!

[PS - I'm starting to write my own Cartman x Kyle fic. I loved this pairing for a very long time now, but it's your fanfic that has inspired me to write my own ;3]
Taboo Love 2008-06-22 . chapter 11
omg! I just have to review. This scene is so achingly romantic. I love Cartman/Kyle and you write this pairing amazingly well, that Matt and Trey would (possibly) be proud^^
KnuxZ 2008-02-23 . chapter 15
omg... I am like, crying. I love this story so much. It's different from other Cartman/Kyle fics... It was just... WOW I can't even think right now because it's 2AM...

What I loved about Sam was that she was just one of those characters who you loved to hate. And I felt some serious hate towards her. The same with Stan at one point in the story... How could someone called a best friend do that...

This was very well done. Great story. What I loved about it is that nothing seemed to go Cartman's way. It pretty much grabbed my attention because I wanted him to get his way. So, of course, I read the whole thing in one sitting and now it's 2AM. It takes a lot to keep me that into a story. You did an amazing job at this.

I choked up at the end when Kyle said, "I don't love you Cartman." Sad endings are great because too many stories around here have happily ever after.
Didn't expect the Style near the end of the story, honestly. It was a nice twist, though. Made me feel more sympathy for Eric even though he's pretty twisted and evil.

One of the things I loved most about this story is that near the middle when Kyle is alone after Sam spread the news around school, it was sort of similar to an experience I had. So I was sort of touched by that as well...

Ah, I babble. Great story. Love it. Defiantly a favorite of mine now.
Loca Bambina 2008-02-17 . chapter 15
WOW that was really good!! yay! *down with samantha*
Loca Bambina 2008-02-17 . chapter 11
ok i've been reading the story (and i LOVE it btw) and i'd been planning to review at the very end, one big huge review, but after this chapter, i just had to say something - the chapter totally gave me shivers, and in a good way. you are an incredible writer, and this is the best south park fanfic i've read! great job!
Caitlin 2007-12-30 . chapter 15
Odd. I feel emotion towards Cartman. In fact I think I feel ... sorry for him.

Wow, you are an incrediable writer to inspire that feeling.
And I want to hug Kyle. Hug him ever so tight. M love.

And Stan and Kyle together was way too cute for words in this story.
punky45 2007-12-14 . chapter 1
great
strider-mystic 2007-08-27 . chapter 15
i see, so in the end, this basically ended up being a stan/kyle fic? well...technically a cartman/kyle/stan fic, or if you want to put it as some people do a style fic, that just makes me laugh, cos its kinda sad, but anyway, but to actually reviewing this terrible piece of crap that you force me to read...lol, only joking, this was brilliant!!

i loved it, cartman was a tad ooc at the end, cos normally he'd kill anyone who pissed him off, but then i s'pose you have that right to change him with age, as you did make him fall in love with kyle after all.

i kinda wished that you'd just killed off samantha by the end of this, i read it wishing that she'd just get hit by a car and die, in my mind, after kyle told her to go home, she did get hit by a car and die, the other thing for it.

once again, i must say that this story is excellent! (spelt excellent right hehe ^_^)

i would like to point out that hitler is cartman's idle, i'm rambling a tad here, so cannot quite remember why i needed to point that out, i just did.

also, i personally think that you should do a comedy spin-off that shows cartman in love of a packet of cheesey-puffs! you put that idea in my head, so don't think that i'm odd because of it!

well...this has been a rather long review...i hope you're happy now!

lol

put the gun down kayti i reviewed!

anyway, yeah...must get back to sorting alerts out.

YOUR STORY ROCKS!

i'm done now...i swear...
yaoivampire 2007-08-15 . chapter 15
Beautiful. Simply beautiful. And that is saying a lot, since it was kind of sad, I usually don't like sad.
tt 2007-08-04 . chapter 15
Oh my word, I fancy this story SO much. Literally, I would go out with it and let it get to 3rd base with me in a night of drunken passion if I could. But instead I'll just settle for reading it again...
jamielovesyou 2007-07-27 . chapter 15
Oh...my...god. That's the best and saddest Cartman x Kyle story ever! Oh god, what a beautiful tragedy! Great work! You're a real talented writer! =]
Return to Top