Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Concrete Angel - Page 1 of 9
Publisher
2008-12-02 . chapter 6
I thought this might be a decent story but the short paragraphs you have posted so far do not make it worth the energy bothering to click the mouse so many times, I mean from what Ive seen so far the story is only just long enough to be a one shot.
TFinger2
2008-08-25 . chapter 7
I saw the abusive review some twit left you. Sorry about that; as Chaucer told prospective readers of the Canterbury Tales, if they do not find it to their liking, then turn another page--as in find someone else's work to read and trash.

*sigh*

My concern here is that you have avoided Madame Pomfrey too much. She might have wanted to send HG to St. M's at first, but after they had continued problems, I find it hard to believe that Mrs W would suggest a Muggle hospital (especially after the conniption she had over Arthur's stitches in CoS!). I also find it impossible that HP would have just let St. M's toss them and not gone straight to Madame P. Combined, I think you have a very serious plot/character hole to sort out.

Similarly, HP's letting them banish him from GP during a premature birth is also unbelievable. The HP we have come to know and (sometimes) love wouldn't have let a.n.y.t.h.i.n.g keep him away from her during that. No weenie healer was going to come up with a locking spell that HP couldn't find a way through, even if he had to wreck most of the hospital to do it.
*Blondie*
2008-06-07 . chapter 7
Hi! I've read 'til chapter 7 right now, and I'd like too give my opinion :)

This is clearly a different story: usually, it's most about the normal, people being brought back from death and things like that (not that that's bad!)..

oops, I slipped off... back to the comment:

your story is, as I said, different, but I like it that way. You create your own little world with characthers everyones know, and that's good. I also like the fact that Voldemort isn't dead, it's a new thing

well, I can't say more right now, I want to read, so I'll read

but hey, don't let super-critical people push you into a wall, go on!

Love
Mark Heffron
2008-05-17 . chapter 22
Excellent ending. It's nice to see that there will be a sequal to this story.

From what I read in the summery (chapter 23) it seems to Harry's story all over again.


-Mark-
Comforting-MindReader
2008-05-15 . chapter 23
Hey Sam!! It's morgan! O. O.O I like it VERY much! POST IT! Please, please? Pretty please with a cherry on top?!
melaniestryder
2008-05-15 . chapter 23
It's Morgan and Laura here. WRITE THE SEQUAL! FAST! And post! Fast, fast, fast, fast, FAST! NOW! Before we hunt you down!
Thank you so very much. I love you. I love you. I love you.
SkyRogue
2007-12-26 . chapter 22
Woowee! Just read through this whole thing in one sitting. I'm excited to read the sequel now, but that might have to wait till tomorrow. Anyway, great story though. Awesome idea. I really liked it. YAY!

-SkyRogue
lauura
2007-10-27 . chapter 22
i really liked them and even if ron came back harry and hermione should be togethor
bye x0x0x0x0
Magical Harmony-A Dark Secret
2007-09-14 . chapter 22
OMG! This is the number one best Harry and Hermione fanfic in the world! I LOVE it! It's just beautiful! You were like BORN to be a writer! The plot was perfect and this is just wonderful! Keep up the great writing!
amsrule
2007-01-11 . chapter 22
WOW! im speechless! that was absolutly amazing. incredible, best ive ever read! that was so awesome. u r a wonderful author!
ImSoOntheBrinkOfInsanity
2006-11-19 . chapter 22
DUDE! That ruled
yauvanika chopra
2006-10-24 . chapter 4
since when did molly weasley start wearing mascara?and shouldn't it have become penelope weasley?other than that it's good.
airwithwater
2006-08-29 . chapter 22
Hey, I know that you said that you were typing up a sequel, but which one is it? Or have you not posted it yet? Let me knbow soon!

~Airwithwater (I'm on a time limit!)
Dani Collins
2006-08-12 . chapter 22
right after i got home from camp and unpacked, the first think i did was run to the computer to see how many of my favorites were done, and i was SO excited to see this one (my favorite of all favorites) got a lot more chapters!

IT WAS AMAZING! I.CAN.NOT.WAIT for the sequal. i didnt get to check to see if you started it yet, but i will right after i submit this.

*~DANiELLE COLLiNS X33~*
5HAD0W
2006-08-11 . chapter 2
Hey his baby has miscarraged and his wife/girlfreind is dead don't you think he would show some emmotion?
Return to Top