I've finished reading all the Brotherhood Stories in the Hunters Tomb, and I can't find any other word to describe it other than, wow, just... wow.
The universe created there is just beyond belief. It's almost like an entirely different show, except the basics stay the same. I especially love the take on Caleb, and everything the boys have been through together.
I love how each story remained not only true to the universe you have created, but also true to the cannon events on the show.
Excellent. Astonishing. Heartfelt, and just, wonderful. I can't wait to read more from the AU. It's highly addictive, and there are so many questions left unanswered. There's just the right balance between the physical and emotional whumpings. Perfect.
Am looking forward to more, and thank you so much for directing me to the site. The stories have much more impact when read in relative order.
You and your cohort, Tidia, are truly talented writers.
FW

This story kills me everytime I read it, but I find myself reading it often, it calls to me and I find it fits Dean so perfectly. He DESERVES to be real, and as sad as this sounds he's real to me. He always will be x :0)

Argh, this makes me teary every time I read it! *sniff*

Its just so... Dean!! Seriously. You really got his character!

Awesome work :)

Naw

I just had to stop and go 'AW!'Velveteen Rabbit has always been a favorite of mine. Adorable Jim and Dean story:D

(Dean’s brows drew together, and his lip quivered slightly. “I mean…to Dad and Sammy…will I be REAL?”... “I really don’t know, Dean,” he replied softly, because he was always truthful. But, God, I hope so.)

Boy, Jim was pretty dumb as a pastor. I think that's he's cue to saya that Dean is real for him.

(Jim couldn’t help to wonder how long it would take for his old friend to understand what his son was missing.)

Another stupidity. He should just tell John, not just wondering.

God, this story is just unbelievable, it squeezed my heart in all the right places, and I love the way you worked a children's story so artfully into this heartwrenching tale. It's truly a piece of art, thank you for putting it up here. You're amazing!

Huggels, Tomorrows Dust

This story is amazing. I know that as a kid I loved that story. It was one of my favorites. I fought with my sister as too who's book it was. And even though it had her name on the inside of it, I still claimed it was mine. Ha-Ha.
Thanks for your story. Well written and everything. Loved it.

This was wonderful. It perfectly illustrates how Dean sees himself to this day. Though he still doesn't realize that to Sam he's been Real for a very long time.

This story broke my heart and brought a tear to my eye. Excellent! ^_^

OK had me crying on that one! My favorite book! Brought back memories to how shabby my book was I read it over and over! Excellent story!

This is my favorite of all your stories. I love th Caleb and Dean stories, but this is the best. It makes me tear up everytime I read it. Thank you for writing it.

Beautiful story!

This just about jerked my heart out. Poignant and touching, down to the depths of the soul.

What an awesome oneshot into what happened right after the Shtriga attacked Sammy. A great insight as to what happened to Dean and what he thought after they got to Pastor Jims!

Wow. I actually had to skim it was too dangerous to read. Like, all sad-scary. Beautifully done, though: heartwrenching.