Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Stargate: Thirdspace - Page 1 of 34
Dr. Sweetz
2009-11-25 . chapter 23
hey this is a great story! please update soon I can't wait for the comming war. also I want to see how well the tau'ri do in the B-5 universe as well!
Pacb
2009-11-12 . chapter 23
This is a great story, one of the few I actually go back and re-read every few updates or even just when I get really bored. All I can really say is keep up the good work.
WraithRune
2009-11-11 . chapter 23
It's nice to read this story again :D
Alastairnyght
2009-11-11 . chapter 23
I've gotta agree with most of the previous reviews. It's a very good story so far and one I'am hoping to see the conclusion of at some point and not just have it trail off into the void of the un-updated.

Also like others though I want to express the wish that you'd use a spelling/grammer checker. The differences between 'there', 'their' and 'they're' being the most obvious ones, but others also abound which makes it distracting at times.
gonqueasel
2009-10-27 . chapter 23
Very interesting - a Stargate Babylon5 crossover story as seen through the lens of David Weber. A reasonably plausible premise (given the precepts of the story) strongly written action sequences and interesting interpolations of the events make for a very fun read. Do watch the minor grammatical difficulties however, they can be quite distracting.
jason864 sg-1
2009-10-25 . chapter 23
This story is crazy good i really like it and cant wait for the next few chapters. It needs more battle scenes though there has only been 1 major fight and u should have more i think. Then again it is your story but really good hurry with the next chapter plz
Nemo Blank
2009-10-23 . chapter 23
Great story, but a few technical nitpicks. You seem to lack the discrimination to distinguish between the words there they're and their. I recommend the purchase of a thesaurus.
TankerMDK
2009-10-14 . chapter 20
besides everything that's going on in this story. i'm surprised you haven't had a team go out of rivendell to the mainland to study the ruins you mentioned. By god you write really good stories. well done. not just for this, but for the other stargate stories too. New Frontier, AD:Divergence, Gods Among Us, and Beyond The Farthest Star has been interesting. Normally i don't read Stargate stories unless they have a crossover that i recognize. but i gave this a chance and i'm glad i did. Your AU stargate stories. top notch.

~TankerMDKâ„¢
lion
2009-10-11 . chapter 23
this story is god
nfall
2009-10-11 . chapter 23
a really cool story, please write more :)
sweetyamiyugigirl
2009-10-10 . chapter 23
O.O, this is bad. Wow that was an undedrstatement, this is really, hugely utterly bad. I hooe that they destroy the Sinhindrea those creatures so have it coming for them.

PLease don't make the Vorlons go crazy!
Ferrugen
2009-10-09 . chapter 23
Awesome story, simply mind blowing! I'm anxiously waiting your next chapter. Hope you won't take as long.
resq188
2009-10-07 . chapter 23
Would it have not been a good idea for the animal to ask the nox about the radiation that is pleging her she ship and crew? Since they have experience dealing with the Sinhindrea and their weapons.
FishGod
2009-10-06 . chapter 23
Thank you! You can't imagine how much I waited for a update.

About the political it was like/dislike kind of thing.Like because its very complex and in depth, dislike that politics is politics and some people are complete idiots and should be publicly executed, most are blowhard meatbags that just looking out for their own political **.

And something that caught my eye are some God references, like "Oh God..","may god help us" do they still believe in God(unlikely) and if yes, what God is it? actually its probably a cultural, societal and vocabulary influences that religion has over us and you added it without noticing or couldn't express yourself any other way.

Plus your Asgard seem a little OC feeling a lot more emotion and not being borderly incompetent. I like that but I don't see them jumping in a war without knowing anything about them just that they attacked a large fleet of warships that moved to their galaxy, for all they knew were an invasion force. Now hearing the nox testimony they would exterminate them with extreme prejudice.

I'm not complaining its really good and please continue and if something offended you in what I wrote here I apologize
angelus288
2009-10-06 . chapter 23
Alright you finally updated. Although I'm disappointed it took place in the stargate universe. I'm much more interested to see what happens in the B5 galaxy, and I'm looking forward to the meeting of Levy and captain McKenzie
Return to Top