No! With Rose's "all right then" I was totally wanting my HEA! So sad, he loves her and either way she is going to die! Ugh!

That was so heartbreaking! *sniff sniff cry* Excellent story!

that deserves some series angst warnings. I nearly cried, and thats hard to do. it was so touching and real, I'm now very sad. But you should be happy, that was amazingly written and very touching.

this is a wonderful story! and so sad! I felt so sorry for Rose when she discovered that her being engaged to the doctor etc was just a dream!

Oh...fantastic...absolutely fantastic...I've read so many slushy shippy stories and none of them have an impact because it's just a little fantasy, but this...this hurt. Well done. Well done.

oh this has got to be THE best fic i have ever read. fabuloso. seriously i cant get over the brilliantness of it. the twists in the storyline, the fact that it was getting fluffy and then didnt. Bloody hell! i loved the humour in it too. 'legging it' classic! you got the angst perfect.
poor Doctor
poor Rose
Summary: may i borrow the catchphrase of everyones favourite 9th Doctor- Fantastic!

LOLuv, Soap Sudd

Aww! That was beautiful. I have actually got tears in my eyes for the first time in I don't know how long.

Aww... Sad and sweet. Very good.
-K

OMG, u really hit a nerve here. All the emotions are perfect: Rose's oain and resolve; the Doctor's anguish; the conclusion is so THEM. I think i'll just go to my corner and die crying...

it's so great. I really like it, all the angst and romance are making me happy.

Gosh. The flow of this is so gorgeous. Your writing is amazing, really, the flow of it is beautiful. You really have a distinct style that I have to say I LOVE, and your writing is so wonderfully precise and careful, it's a softer kind of angst that makes the reader empathize even more. Sorry about this pitiful review, but I have to say, you write very, very, VERY well, and it just comes through so simply in the first paragraphs of this fic. The only think I could reproach would be the lack of 'solidity' if you see what I mean to it...it was written to be read as a 'loose' writing, as far as I can tell, and maybe if you'd...I don't know...made some bits a bit more...'sharp'...Gosh, I'm sorry about this review. It really does suck, and I'm not being clear. Well, whatever, this is gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous! & definately goes as a fave. =) x

that was good, a little bit of rip your heart out it wasn't real and then to pretend it didn't happen. Very good I loved it.