| Reviews for “Keep It” |
|---|
EstelPax 5/16/13 . chapter 1Great job. I loved the idea and it worked, perfectly. |
ibelieveintruelove 11/15/09 . chapter 1Its so sad. But it makes me wonder what would have happened if they decided to not marry. Would the galaxy have been better off? Or worse, since Luke and Leia would never have been born to redeem their father and save the galaxy. Very nice story, good job! |
Admiral Lily 10/26/08 . chapter 1Deep. And painful. But most things of this nature are. |
lotzaluv 6/1/08 . chapter 1Loved it...sad though. |
eirene1988 8/18/07 . chapter 1I love this. So tragic, so touching. Beautiful. |
puddle of cookies 3/19/07 . chapter 1 This was good. The only thing is that the scene is from The Fellowship of the Ring not TT. I liked the parelles though. |
suspensegirl 11/10/06 . chapter 1I liked it. It was really cool. |
fAteD lOvE 7/18/06 . chapter 1I loved it, please continue writing |
marie fay 6/16/06 . chapter 1aw. so sad... (but good) |
Jedi Master Evenstar 6/5/06 . chapter 1loved it! just 1 question: what timeframe does this story take place? Before or after AotC? either way, it was good. I'm a Lord of the Rings dork as well as a Star Wars nerd and a Harry Potter freak, AND PROUD OF IT ALL! |
QueenNaberrie 6/4/06 . chapter 1WAH! How sad. :,( Despite the fact that I like happy endings where Anakin and Padme end up together, this was wonderfully written and I applaud you. *claps* Well done. |
QueenMeep 6/4/06 . chapter 1First off, yes, I can definitely see how this was inspired by the scene in LOTR with the King and his elven lover. Very poignant... and again, you are excellent with the little details, the setting up of the scenery and what it looks like around them. I can see it in my head, clear as day. And there you are with the symbolism again, with their names, their planet of origins... I love how you've tied that in, yet again. Perfect. Perfect. Perfect. I, for one, am more fond of the more profound sad endings than the happy endings. I adore this. And I love seeing writers use the japor snippet... How underused THAT symbol is! But you, the Queen of the Underused, of course know how to do that. ;) |
indigrl 6/3/06 . chapter 1I loved the scene in LOR and you did a wonderful job converting it to Star Wars. My only problem is that it says complete I would have love to see the story play out perhaps with and ending similar to LOR Return of the King. |
bluebuggy 6/2/06 . chapter 1 Have you seen Lord of thr Rings? Just wondering... Great job! |
Zoe 6/2/06 . chapter 1 Loved it! |