Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Extinguished - Page 1 of 2
Child of a Pineapple
2007-07-24 . chapter 1
...Now I feel like I need to watch the movies again...

Great job!
Cestari
2006-11-12 . chapter 1
I love this story.
ContradictoryOrien
2006-11-04 . chapter 1
X3 I think you captured his (St.John/Pyro 's) character really well, and I enjoyed this story a lot. I loved the way you portrayed everyone too.
SupportSeverusSnape
2006-10-30 . chapter 1
-sobs- Why is that beautiful? I love Pyro, Magneto, and Mystique!! -sobs some more-
Eclipse75
2006-06-18 . chapter 1
WOW that was VERY good to bad it's only a 1 chapter fic (*sob* how sad) anyway great work
Adriana
2006-06-15 . chapter 1
I loved this, I`m only sad that there isn`t any more of it to read. This is the best X-Men one-shot I`ve read in... ever, really. Awesometastic job.
im36degrees
2006-06-15 . chapter 1
so good! you're a really great writer!
pat-nosferatu
2006-06-07 . chapter 1
Wow Brilliant fic. Great ending to the X3:) And about my favourite character- Pyro.
Morganfae
2006-06-05 . chapter 1
Wow, that was amazing! Other then a few tiny spelling errors here and there, evertything else was great! I hope to see more from you soon!

-Laura
abbynormal360
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
aww... this is so god...
i wish it wasn't a one-shot... =T-T=
Laly Weasley
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
wow I loved this story, really loved it...it's excellent and you are a very good writer
Stranded
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
It's a shame you won't be making this multi chaptered. Your writing is addictive and solid.

It is a rare thing to find someone with your skills. I am a big fan of Pyro and X3 bugged me. Especially with leaving Pyro's fate hanging. What happened to him. I enjoy your solution.

It is also good to see grammar and spelling used correctly. Most people need a beta but not you.

I look forward to any other Pyro centric stories from you. And maybe pray that you will continue this one somehow.
zshp1411
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
This was a really good story. I had wondered what had happened to Pyro at the end of the third movie.
It'sKindaSadReally.
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
Wonderful story!
Your writing style is brillant and even thought it was a one shot I think maybe you should make another one ^_^
guest
2006-06-04 . chapter 1
Awwe! I really love this fic. It answered so many questions that I had while walking out of the theater: What happened to Pyro? Will the government arrest Mystique after she gave away the camp location? and many more.

I love the almost fatherly-son relationship between Pyro and Magneto. The way that Erik held John back on the bridge seemed like such a fatherly thing to do. I always thought that he cared for Pyro and not just because of his powers and your story shows exactly that. Man, I thought that I was the only one who thought that.

I also like how understanding Mystique is in this story. She doesn't exactly seem like the maternal type, yet she plays the role so well. The entire bit about the chess pieces (Magneto = King, Mystique = Queen, Pyro = Bishop) was excellent. Totally believable too. It makes the three of them seem like one little, messed up family of sorts. They truly care for the well-being of each other, and I think that is so sweet. Your tale truly brought that familial feeling to light. I love it!

It was nice to see the X-Men accept John back into the mansion, although I did think that they were a little bit harsh on him (he was injured after all). It's totally believable that Wolverine would knock him out, especially considering his emotional state at the time. It's just too hard to believe that Bobby would also smack him around after John woke up. Oh well.

All together, I must say nicely done. You made a believable story about the events after X3 that answered all of my questions. Too bad this is only a one-shot, because I would have loved to read more about Pyro and his struggles for survival and acceptance. Beautiful story!
Return to Top