 Echo Moon 2009-11-20 . chapter 3odd.. i just had to log in even though i was logged in a minute ago... hmm... oh yeah, the review. uh... this is funny. and you should write more. |
 Amythista 2009-09-01 . chapter 1AWESOMENESS. That is all that needs to be said. |
 goddessa39 2009-08-05 . chapter 3Yeah, these things really bug me too. I mean, really! If you're going into hiding there is no way you let someone else have the secret unless they are a bery large piece to your survival or with you, like the Jews hiding from Nazis. |
 Jeff 2009-01-06 . chapter 1 This is in response to you H/HR Shipper commandants. I hated HBP after I read it but figured that i giver JKR another chance seeing that book 1-5 were some of the most well thought out and writing books that i have read. However the way she wrapped up the series left me no choice but to sell all seven of my books to a used book store down the street from my house and stick to FF.
JSG |
 Lord Sia 2008-11-27 . chapter 3Poor, poor Voldemort. Just goes to show, just because you're powerful and evil doesn't mean you're clever and successful. Oh, I know! Why didn't they have Peter swear upon his magic that he wouldn't betray them? I understand the life part, I mean, if he was tortured to the point where he wanted to die just to end it... But come on? And Sirius, your best friend and his wife were just killed by your other friend: you're Harry's godfather, Dumbles didn't have any say in the matter and if Hagrid resisted it would have been kidnapping. Dumbles; how did you know everything about what happened and Harry's scar and everything, without visiting? And if you did, why would you not pick Harry up? I mean, a whole day passed before he was left on the doorstep... Hmm...
Keep it up, like this! |
 Lord Sia 2008-11-27 . chapter 2You know, on a second thought, maybe I don't want to be an Animagus anymore. Peter lost what little spine he had, Sirius turned into an overaffectionate, non-sensical mutt, and James became an arrogant ** who still got the girl... Maybe there's some point to it after all? Hm... Decisions, decisions... |
 Lord Sia 2008-11-27 . chapter 1Nice, you inspired me to make a "commandments of the HP/LL ship". And oh, Voldi-chan does SO remind me of a cunning little kitten... Vicious little buggers, those... |
 RandomDream 2008-08-06 . chapter 3Good (great!) point..s. |
 macaday me a nut 2008-04-01 . chapter 3Ha ha ha ha ha!! This was freaken hilarious! I loved it so much. I was laughing the intire way through. And the little bits with Voldemort! Ha ha haha...It also had some valid questions...hmm...I wonder...??
Macaday me a nut (and your one too!) |
 Vilkath 2007-12-26 . chapter 3Love this fic, it brought up a lot of the logical statements that have been said here and there. Pretty much almost none of the finer points in the HP world makes any logical sense, unless Dumbledoor is evil or manipulative in some way planing for Lily and James to die by selling them out etc. |
 shazia Born confused 2007-11-10 . chapter 3yaeey! i always (well, not literally always, but still...) wondered why they just didn't do the fidelius and be their own secret keepers, too.
and i wondered abt how someone finds out what you-know-whose name is when noone ever says it
and i like the way uv layed it out, it was funny!
tc
:) |
 VampireApple 2007-10-21 . chapter 3Ah, this was so cool. Thanks for writing it. |
 VampireApple 2007-10-21 . chapter 2Ah, this was funny. |
 VampireApple 2007-10-21 . chapter 1Ah, I love the HHR ship. Its my favorite (after JL) and none of my friends like it. The first one with Harry and Dumbledore was so funny.
And Voldie is a bif ifiot for marking his followers like that. Its bugged me too. |
 Baruma 2007-10-07 . chapter 3Haha, actually a bunch of questions that I have asked myself. And personally HBP and DH are bothersome. Maybe Dark!JKR wrote it!
11. Thou shalt not laugh/cry when ever you see a copy of HBP or DH, expecially in the middle of the store.
And considering my boyfreind yelled at me to shut up and ran from the room as I ranted, did I break number four?
Sun-chan* |