 the-smallthings23 2009-07-31 . chapter 25wow, what an entrancing story. it was so good i couldn't stop read it.
really good!
btw, in the second last chapter how she's reading her speech, if you wanted to chance it, the saying goes more like
"some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them" or something and i'm sure it was written by shakespeare.
im gonna check out your other stories.
keep writting :) |
 Daniel 2009-07-18 . chapter 1 Of course your writing is better in the end, you've practiced for the story. :D |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 25A beach… the perfect place to end a story like yours. =) I must say Ms. Goodwitch, this has been one of the most unique, intricate, moving and compelling fanfictions I’ve ever read. Fancy words aren’t enough to express admiration. =) Cheer’s to A Shadow’s Requiem and the truly gifted author, and friend. =) |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 24The WORST chapter you’ve ever Goodwitch! You are despicable, profoundly immoral, insufferable, hard-hearted, wicked, not to mention CRACKED! The speech you wrote was superficial, shallow, frivolous! And that Ron-Mione moment in the end was repulsive and vomitous. I have never read a more horrendous ending! Yet, I can be an eminent LIAR at outbursts of intense joy and sadness at the same time.
Don’t hex me! All right, here’s the truth. I have never read a fanfic with such power, magic, intensity and sincerity, since—well, ever. You made me weep and I swear, I don’t do that often. =p There just aren’t enough words to describe how proud I am of you. You’re a gifted person. I’ve said it a thousand times and I can go on saying it infinity. A Shadow’s Requiem—brilliant. Goodwitch008—brilliant. BLOODY BRILLIANT. =) |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 23In sleep he sang to me… In dreams he came… I knew it! I knew he was going to use Hermy to get Abby back! I guess good! Soulmates… aw. |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 22I want a locket like that. T.T Aw… utter sweetness! Brilliantly written. Ron wants to dance, eh? Whoa. Lol. Muggle singers? Bwaha.. you’re hilarious! You posted this chap on the day of your birthday/ I didn’t forget to greet you, did I? Well, happy super belated birthday then. =) You have such knowledge on clothes. Are you like some fashion deity or something? Lol. Good job. On to the next… |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 21Aw! Ron hugged his wittle siwstew! That’s so sweet! Hermione Weasley. Perfect. =) Where did you get that idea about the stacks? Lol. Love the way Ron addresses Hermione as ‘Mione. =) “And not as a last resort.” Wow. You always, always amaze me, mate. =) |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 20Poor Harry. Off to finish Voldie up all by himself. =( I’m sure he’s really depressed and all, and with Ginny missing. =( Well, Hermy and Ron have their own probs to worry about anyway. Aw, it doesn’t matter if you made Ron’s eye color green. Rupert has green eyes anyway. Lol. |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 19Damn watch. =) Ron-Herm fluffiness! Aw! So sweet! “I don’t want to lose you…” Luna whistles out bubbles! Aw! I wish I had one of those! You write quidditch moves very easily, eh? Wow. Weasel’s have nine lives, don’t they? Lol. You won’t kill Ron off. You’re the bestest goodwitch there is. You couldn’t do such a thing. Could you? |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 18I love Lumina! She’s even wackier than Luna! Moonlilies and Pyreflies… they’re so original. Where do you get all these ideas? Why the heck did Abby hurt the werewolf even if she knew it was Richard? T.T Hermione wouldn’t have done that. I wish there were guys like Richard who existed in the real world. Sigh. Lol. I haven’t got the slightest clue of what Richard plans to do to Hermione. Ok, maybe I do… Bwaha |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 17Whoa! It IS long! About 30+ pages long if I’m not mistaken. =) All those memories made me feel like I was in them myself. You know so much! You wrote this chapter hands down, didn’t you? Very beautifully spun. |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 16You killed Ginny?! YOU KILLED GINNY?! It’s all right. I didn’t like her for Harry anyway. Lol. Kidding. (2) I love that bit with Kandice! (3) Hermione wants dozen of kids in the future, eh? Sweet! (4) I envy Parvati! |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 12A howler! Yes! I want to receive one too! Poor Hermione.. in so much pain. =( Ron--oh no! I love this chapter. =) Could feel the heat rise up. |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 11Richard's a werewolf. Richard's cold. Richard's hot. Lol. Therefore, Richard is.. warm? Wow. Harry ahead in class? Well, good for him. Bad for Hermione. >. |
 Wet Water Witch 2008-06-08 . chapter 7poor ron.. =( aw, he can have me! i dont want a rich and famous boyfriend. >. |