|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| eideticMeMoRy22 2008-02-26 ch 8, | abusei loved it! |
| Mally Lunacy 2006-10-21 ch 8, | abuseAwesome story! |
| AddictionToFiction 2006-08-24 ch 8, | abuseAww, I enjoyed that. Thanks. :] |
| Pacee_86 2006-08-13 ch 1, anon. | abuseYeah I totally agree with CeceLeste about the girlfriend thing. It's always a huge mistake. Respect the character. Always. Anyway, the "day" is over and the story says "complete" so obviously it's not an issue here. Personally, I don't think Soda would be bugging (or asking) Pony about girls in that way. Soda knows Pony better than that, and he would not ever try to push him into something that he is too young for... But otherwise, it was a kind of sweet little chat between the brothers. A nice way to end it. I would have liked to have seen more Darry/Pony interaction in the story - that is the really interesting relationship. The most profound and most compelling relationship in the book. I would have liked to have seen more of it, and with Darry being a little more in character than he was here - again, respect the character. But in spite of these issues, it was a good story. Congrats. Nice job. |
| CeceLeste 2006-08-13 ch 8, anon. | abuseThat was sweet, but Pony definitely does NOT need a girlfriend at this point. I absolutely can't stand it when fanfic authors try to throw a girlfriend into Pony's life long before he is ready... it's one of the worst things. He just turned 14. He's not interested in girls in that way yet. It's made very clear. It's really awful when authors don't respect that. I'm not criticizing your writing. I think what you wrote here was very nice. I'm just making a general comment, because I think someone else said that Pony needed a girlfriend, and it's just not true... the character needs to be handled gently and appropriately, and he needs to be respected just as he is... really. Anyway, nice story you have here, although I think there was a bit of OOC-ness in some chapters. Overall, very nice though. |
| -blue-oyster-cult-love- 2006-08-11 ch 8, | abuseaw...pony does need a girlfriend...hes seems a bit lonely. lol but anyway! yay! chapter was gooD! |
| XAmberX 2006-08-11 ch 8, | abuseO...Is there a girl. *hint hint* |
| soda'slover 2006-08-11 ch 8, | abuseAww, I love Pony!!I'd line up for him!Graet chapter, update soon please!! |
| An-Jelly-Ca 2006-08-11 ch 8, | abuseGreat chapter! Update sooN! It was really good! :@) |
| An-Jelly-Ca 2006-08-08 ch 7, | abuseGreat chapter! I love the story! Update soon! |
| -blue-oyster-cult-love- 2006-08-06 ch 7, | abuseaw...it was like a little flashback chapter. yay! update sooN! |
| soda'slover 2006-08-05 ch 7, | abuseAw,remenacing pass times.Poor Darry,Pony, and Soda.They'er so cute!!Great chapter,update soon!! |
| SamSammySamantha 2006-08-05 ch 7, | abuseWell, you are on my Favorite Authors list. Every fic I ready that you wrote is at the very least, great. Another great fic. Update soon! |
| XAmberX 2006-08-05 ch 7, | abuseCHICKEN FEVER! OW! Anywho. I'm bored. That was refreshing. New Chapter! :D lol -Amber |
| soda'slover 2006-07-28 ch 6, | abuseThats good they'er keeping ther promise! Great chapter, update soon!! |