 ! 2007-01-25 . chapter 3 i'm not really into the whole powerful or experianced Neville! |
 4evrXknightXpixie 2006-11-14 . chapter 3I love your story so far. It's great! |
 4evrXknightXpixie 2006-11-14 . chapter 1I like your story so far. |
 lane 2006-10-01 . chapter 6 Draco asking "is dad evil" is a very nice touch, makes us remember how child like and innocent he really is..you seem to have him acting more mature in this story..like a calm respectable pureblood child should..that little outburst proves that he's human. |
 Lane 2006-10-01 . chapter 5 Very intriguing with Lucius being gone...and draco thinking him dead..i suppose this is going to make him lose his trust in his mother.. I want to hear more about this situation. how will draco be changed without his fathers influence?
Do you think you could elaborate a bit on how he managed to nick a wand and how he knew those spells inthe first place? Has he been regularly sneaking into his parents private library to learn before school does he have a private tutor or does narcicessa just encourage him to learn ahead of his peers? I always found it odd that 11 was the age when hogwarts started...i mean are pureblood kids taught to control their magic sooner...do they get a wand before thier 11th birthday...i mean obviously they don't just "come into their magic" because there has been uncontrolled magic before kids reach 11. I like the touch of Snape calling Draco brat..almost like a term of endearment. Though i think you should add in a bit more sarcasm or atleast bluntness or even extremly complex..knowlegable sentances to snapes dialog..its pretty obvbious that he was a book worm..and is a very smart man. Just need to bring a little bit more into his character. |
 Lane 2006-10-01 . chapter 4 I'm not enjoying the chapter on neville (i think i mispelled his name) I like him as a character and i like that you are going to have him friends with Harry personally i thought he was a more interesting character than ron..but thats the thing..you aren't letting much of Nevilles personality show through in this and the transaction is a bit boring and confusing.
On to Harry and his friend...The snake next to the wolf cub..why didn't it talk to harry...or was it snape? can you elaborate a bit more on that entire scene..it was a little rushed. I like that you are using snape to look out for harry..especially against DUmbledores wishes...and i like that you are having Harry's orphanage experience to be diffrent than how most portray tom riddle's. QUite a few fiction i have read has Harry going through the same motions as Riddle and this is a nice change. Ok..i wanted to get all that out before i forgot..please don't take it as a flame please use peoples suggestions and critisism to help you improve your writing. |
 HarryPotter'sCharmed 2006-10-01 . chapter 1Looks like a good story so far...
I look forward to reading more... |
 Seku238 2006-09-25 . chapter 5 Will Harry, Draco and Neville be friends? Keep updating please cos its a good fic. |
 Never Forgotten RIP Barbaro 2006-07-13 . chapter 1this story is great! I can't wait for a update!
They Will Not Be Forgotten AD-CD-SB-LP-JP
'Those who love us never truly leave us' Albus Dumbledore |