Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Roses of Joy, Thorns of Pain - Page 1 of 2
Dreaming while awake 12/27/11 . chapter 11
NOOOOO! *sobs* I'm not cut out for this (runs away crying) Still, amazing story, horribly sad but good.
darkbloodymoon 4/27/09 . chapter 12
hope you start on the next one soonzes!
Alia G. L 10/29/06 . chapter 12
*cries* That was so sad. That was so depressing. *runs to get tissues* Poor everyone! Especially Elrohir! Great ending, though. I personally can't wait for the next story. It's going to be great!
Ellfine 10/10/06 . chapter 11
How very very sad...
Alia G. L 10/8/06 . chapter 11
*sobs* Oh, my. That was so sad. Even knowing... it was so sad. I sobbed through this whole chapter. Beautifully written, but so sad. It was horrible. *sobs* Please make it all better... please make it all better... *sigh*, but you can't. Please post the next chapter soon, though.
Alia G. L 9/29/06 . chapter 10
*falls over sobbing* That was so sad! I can't believe you killed Kalen! I mean, he was evil but that was just so sad. Perfect ending, though. I just hope Linriel is all right. Please post the next chapter soon. I can't wait to find out what happens!
leralonde 9/24/06 . chapter 9
How exciting! I love the thought of a new little elfling. Maybe he would look like Legolas. I suppose she could too. No mention of Aragorn. I'm sure they haven't forgotten him, so what is coming?
Alia G. L 9/24/06 . chapter 9
*smiles happily* She's going to have a baby! That's so exciting! I can't wait to see whether or not it's a boy or a girl. I loved this chapter. Their friendly banter was wonderful. Please post the next chapter soon!
Alia G. L 9/9/06 . chapter 8
Beautiful chapter. I loved it. I absolutely loved it. So sweet. *sighs happily* So good. Great chapter, like always. I can't wait for the next one. Please post it soon!
Alia G. L 9/2/06 . chapter 7
Evil Kalen. Evil Kalen. Someone should like hit him over the head. He was so mean. I can't believe he did that. And poor Arwen... nobody's telling her what happened... very frustrating. Excellent chapter (like always). I can't wait to get to the wedding! Next chapter soon please.
Alia G. L 8/24/06 . chapter 6
*cries* Oh, how cruel! You're so evil. Evil, I tell you. This was just so sad. Made me sob it did. I can't believe you did it. Will things get better? They better get better. *sniffles* Please post the next chapter soon.

P.S. This chapter was still really good, despite Aragorn leaving and all that. :(
Alia G. L 8/22/06 . chapter 5
A figure in the shadows? Not good. Not good. Awesome chapter. I loved it. "Should make sure Elladan hasn’t lost your ring. I swear he’s trying to lose it" I admit, I about died laughing when I read that line. It was perfect. Absolutely perfect. I can't wait for the next chapter. Please post it soon!
The Battling Bard 8/21/06 . chapter 5
Hey, cool story. The only problem I'm having is with this 'Grandma Galadrial' thing; it's seriously getting on my nerves. I think you should leave it as Grandmother (and cut out the Galadrial); it's far more elegant sounding. Elrohir, Elladan and Arwen are the noblest people in Middle-earth, they're not a bunch of chavvy Rohirrim.
Alia G. L 8/18/06 . chapter 4
How sweet! I love the twins together. Beautiful chapter. It was extrememly well written. I can't wait for the next one. Please post it soon!
Aranna Undomiel 8/14/06 . chapter 3
Finally found some time to start on your new story, and I'm glad I did.

Really liked this last chapter, really funny that last part especially, with those questions. Like how you did that :)

PLease update soon
22 found: Page 1 2 Next »
Return to Top