Wow. I don't think I have ever read a oneshot that has put so many different emotions in me at one time.

I mean, throughout the whole story, I was feeling angry, sad, and just confused. For some reason this story like, made me rethink my whole life. I don't know...it was kind of wierd.

I don't really know what to think of this story, it wasn't bad...so I guess it was good--in a strange sort of way.

Am I making any sense?

I have never come across someone with such a unique writing stle as yours. It was really neat, and I liked that.

Over all, I believe this is a positive review. This is good...it just made me feel like, really...[?] mixed emotions, I guess.

HoistTheColours

hi just thought I'd say I liked your story. Kinda took a different take on things, I wish it had been longer. I hope you continue. :)

this is gorgeous. really.

Arrggh...that was beautiful, you got all the characters just right.

Thanks for making my day.:)

Jay

I'm originally a fan of your GG stuff, although I'm amazed at how well your work translates across fandoms. Brilliant.

Wow. Just effing WOW. That was amazing. I don't know why you don't have more reviews, because this story is one of the best PotC fanfics I've read. Great characterization - I love the fact that you fleshed out Will believably and likeably, and you really hit the Will-Elizabeth-Jack tension on the head. Brilliant. Please write more.

I loved this. It's amazing, really incredible. I can definitely picture this happening.

Amazing. Simply brilliant.

Very sad to me, but very very lovely. Well done.

aw

some W&E i actually like..

pirate

After the movie there has been a tidal wave of PotC fic and I haven't had the heart(or the stomach) to read any of them. Except yours. And I'm very glad I did. Wonderful. Thank you for treating Will fairly, you had him perfect. And you actually made me like Elizabeth(which has never happened before). You have a great grasp on the characters.

That was fantastic! This is the first in-character, extremely well-writen, and heartwrenching Will/Elizabeth angst fic I've ever read!

This was beautiful. So heartbreakingly sad, but so wonderfully told. I love the way it's written, and I love the dialogue. It's not your typical story, that's for sure. I'm adding it to my favorites.