Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: Halloween, 1981
DeSilva 2006-09-22 . chapter 1
;_;

Short and to the point. But it still made my eyes water.
Jesse Hayes 2006-09-09 . chapter 1
OMG - This is incredible! I'm sad it's only a oneshot, but it's so beautiful and powerful. Love it!
ms james potter 2006-08-05 . chapter 1
that was really good. beautifully written.
Ravenclaw Steph 2006-08-04 . chapter 1
That was fantastic!
MidnightBlue88 2006-08-04 . chapter 1
Ugh, you're really good at these angsty one-shots, you know. And I use the word angst with the utmost affection.

I tried to imagine what Sirius was thinking and feeling when all of this was going on, and I think you captured his rage and grief really well. I liked this line: "The sudden savage rage cuts through his horror like a knife and Sirius stands, knees cracking painfully." That was a very vivid picture.

Sirius thinking about James's sacrifice was so sad, and the few words of dialogue were really poignant. I also like the way you ended it, with Harry crying. It was perfect. Great job, for the bazillionth time.
Return to Top