Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Volcano Day
Spoofmaster 2/5/10 . chapter 1
As a story about healing the relationship between the three of them, this set-up actually works better than if they had managed to make it to Pompeii on time to go Jack-spotting. Makes me wonder if the TARDIS knew she'd meet herself there if she did take them to when they wanted to go.

Adding this to my C2, the Tin Dog.
123-321 3/25/09 . chapter 1
LOVED IT!

man it would have been bad to have, not only see Jack before they met him, but also see the Doctor with Donna XD

actually the whole time i was watching the Pompeii episode i was wondering where Jack was :p

THE TARDIS KNEW! XD
Whirlwind421 11/17/08 . chapter 1
Great story!
wyldcat 11/8/06 . chapter 1
Ooh, I like this one. The one thing that still bothers me about this story is that the Doctor never explained why he left Rose and Mickey for Reinette when he knew there was this possibility that he'd never see them again. Like, Rose never asked him if it was a spur of the moment decision and he realised his mistake later, or that he'd actually thought it through and decided he preferred Reinette to Rose. Other than that, I thought your story was great, and I laughed out loud when they kept ending up at the wrong time in Pompeii. Good work!
forestwife 11/6/06 . chapter 1
really liked this story. pity they never reached Jack though.
Ariadne'sThread 8/20/06 . chapter 1
Loved the ending lol! Pefect Dr Who logic and you got the characters about right, especially Micky.
LarielRomeniel 8/8/06 . chapter 1
So many wonderful moments in this story! Adding it to my favorites list and off to find your other stuff!
Scout Girl 8/7/06 . chapter 1
That was good I really got into it
Strange Principles 8/7/06 . chapter 1
The wit in this is just so amazing, and as for the times they kept stepping out of the TARDIS... priceless. That made me laugh for a VERY long time. Made me alot happier seeing as the last fic I wrote (Angels Fall the hardest - would appreciate a review *wink* :) was very sad. Or I thought so. I also think the comment about Adam was great... you know, I'd almost forgotten about him, but the fact that plants tried to eat him... fantastic! I never did like him much. Congrats on the consistent and impeccable grammar all the way through. I also think the way you made Mickey stand out is well deserved for him and I greatly approve. Mickey desrves a bit more credit :) The references to School reunion were seamlessly put in and created a very good effect (or is it affect?). the title is intriguing and made me want to find out what happened, at least. The humour written throughout is cleverly incorporated, used in all the right places - and the slightly more thoughtful parts fit together well, making this a wholly very enjoyable fan fiction.:)

Thanks for it!

SP

PS: "Angels Fall the Hardest" - really would like a review :) If you have the time, much appreciated :)
Return to Top