 Hamfast Gamgee 2009-11-01 . chapter 1Very nice, I like this keep it up! Nice gentle start setting the scene which I like then the story gets moving. Good bit of Fanfic. |
 ellfine 2009-10-30 . chapter 5 This is possibly the best chapter yet. You have captured the bewilderment and the confused fear of the Teleri so well. I'm worried about Calmea though. I can't wait for more! |
 Clodia 2009-05-01 . chapter 4This is lovely, and a really good idea. You capture the uncertainty and helplessness of the 'little people' very nicely. The hesitation of the Teleri vs the forcefulness of the Noldor is nicely balanced. Thank you! |
 ellfine 2009-04-28 . chapter 4 what an unsettling adventure this character has found herself on!
I worry about what she will see next and who she knows who might fall at the point of a Noldorin sword. |
 SoConfusified 2008-06-27 . chapter 3Wow, I think I started reading this a long, long time ago.
YES! AN UPDATE!
Either way, I thought this was great, and don't worry about the speeches. You did very well!
;)
Just in case I haven't read this before, I shall favorite it! |
 Violin Ghost 2007-05-08 . chapter 2I like this story-- well-written and extremely interesting. It's nice to see these events from the point of view of a Teleri.
Looking forward to the next chapter!
Violin Ghost |
 Dead-Luthien 2007-05-04 . chapter 2I'm glad you updated! |
 emrys 2007-05-03 . chapter 2 it's good. the characters will encounter tragedy no doubt... but they feel like survivors...the easiest thing to get over writer's block (for me anyway) is to picture the future and then figure out how they all got there... I'm sure you'll get over the block. You've got a good writing style. Here's hoping for another update...:-) |
 Ellfine 2007-05-03 . chapter 2I am enjoying this story. It is good to finally see an update!
It would be nice if with the next update you add n a little family tree or explanation of the relationships of the characters to each other. There are so many OCs that it's hard to keep track of who is who.
Looking forward to more! |
 Ellfine 2006-08-16 . chapter 1WOW! This is really great! The characters are well developed and the momentum of the scene is just right for the situations at hand. I can't wait to read more. |
 Celegorm 2006-08-16 . chapter 1This was fairly good until the 'killer fog' bit. Ah, well. No ones perfect.
Celegorm |
 The Battling Bard 2006-08-13 . chapter 1Good start, this looks like it could be intersting, especially as your main character is betrothed to a Noldo. |
 Dead-Luthien 2006-08-13 . chapter 1wow! Really well written. |