Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Sword for Gryffindor - Page 1 of 2
IllegalLadles
2009-08-10 . chapter 1
You know, now that you mention it...
LOL. Great fic, great characterization, great humor :)
-Rayne
shadowninja-yuna
2009-04-26 . chapter 1
Hahaha, they're just so cute :) the founders I mean. Loved the story!
Steven Kodaly
2009-04-06 . chapter 1
I had never really thought about the practicalities of the weapon Harry pulled out of the Hat.
kittydemon18
2008-01-08 . chapter 1
it's a cute story and i like salazar's explination for why rowena gave him the sword and i love godric's response to salazar's reminder
Lady Tragic
2007-07-26 . chapter 1
Heheh. This made me grin. The last few sentences of your AN as much as the story itself. ^.^

~Tragic
(Ain't I Just?)
phoenix-rises-from-the-ashes
2007-07-19 . chapter 1
LOVE IT!
petites sorcieres
2007-02-23 . chapter 1
hahaha ^-^I like it !Good one shot !Yeha you're right. You probably the only person who think that Godric sword is his ornement sword!
lirance
2007-01-28 . chapter 1
Absolutely fantastic. Clever, very well characterised and hilariously funny. Loved it!
Junsui
2006-12-01 . chapter 1
Haha! That was great! You're right; I never thought of it that way at all.
The Undying Mongoose
2006-11-15 . chapter 1
*laughs very loudly, drawing strange looks from the kids in the library* I completely agree that the sword is a bit ostentatious. Draco dormiens nunquam vexatus!
shilps
2006-09-02 . chapter 1
marvelous! i actually like the a/n and the idea that harry slew the basilisk using "Godric's mantelpiece ornament". i dunno some kinda humor there. anyways...it was real cute and i like that it was from salazar's pov and not godric's, which may have been slightly random. good job!
horn-head
2006-08-30 . chapter 1
This was FANTASTIC!! Loved it. Is this a one-shot? 'Cuase I could see this as a continuing fic. Rowena getting Godric odd gifts, like a bright shiny new hat with a big plume... Or maybe another one-shot of Harry finding Godric's REAL sword and wondering who would ever have wanted something that's covered in dull brown spots. Hehe, have the plot bunnies if ya want 'em. You just gave me one or two. :p

HH
Wolf By Night
2006-08-29 . chapter 1
I LOVE this! It's very clever and witty.

I had actually noticed the sword as well, and I've always thought that there's no way Godric Gryffindor would use a sword that shiny or puny. It seemed REALLY small to me, as well as flamboyant.

Anyway, I really enjoyed this little fic. Godric amused me. =D

- WBN
Symbolist
2006-08-25 . chapter 1
This is brilliant. So very, very Gryffindor-like to prefer a simple, useful tool over an extravagant weapon that is basically useless because of its weight. And I like that you hinted at Rowena/Godric (at least, I thought you did... but I tend to pull things out of thin air because I like Rowena/Godric, so if you didn't intentionally put Rowena/Godric in, then I apologize... but if it's there on purpose, then I love it! Haha... ha... I'm so not funny. And if you're like me you'll show this review to your friend and be like, "Wow... some fanfiction reviewers are so strange...") But in the end, it's a great little story. :-)
Gwinna
2006-08-23 . chapter 1
I'd never thought about that, but you're right, Godric would go for usefulness rather than ornamentation in a sword. This story makes it rather ironic that Harry uses that sword to kill the basilisk. Maybe it was pointless, but it was funny... Good job! You should write more about the Founders!
Return to Top