 Lonespirit 5/22/04 . chapter 1Takes some guts to redo an ending to such a good movie. Most of your reviewers seem to like it.
The few that are giving constructive criticism, however, seem to be getting an earful from *Emily*. While I agree that full out flaming is absolutely no use to anyone, I can honestly tell you that most of the reviewers only typed constructive criticism.
While it was a little too sappy for my taste, I still enjoyed the idea of Christian and Satine being together in the end. Keep writing! |
 CurleyEM 1/24/02 . chapter 9Aww a happy ending to a happy (fab) movie/fanfic. |
 Caroline 1/7/02 . chapter 9A wonderful ending to a wonderful romance! SO much better than how the movie turned out! I loved it! |
 ladymarmaladepottertoo lazy to sign in 1/6/02 . chapter 9 AWWWWW This fanfic was sooooooooooooooooo cool! I loved it! *sings cheerfully* "Come what may..." |
 Emily 1/2/02 . chapter 9 hey, wonderful story, i loved the ending! you did a great job-
To those who just cant settle for something different, get over it. So what if the author has Marie be married to Zidler, it's ficiton! this site is called fanFICTION.net isn't it?Thankyouverymuch!
I hope someone else makes an alternate ending story , it was a good idea. All you see in the Moulin Rouge catagory is Angst stories!Thank god someone is original! ) |
 Panra 1/2/02 . chapter 9okay i'm going to have to agree with you. I never heard Marie being reffered to as Madam Zidler, though many people think she is. I've watched it close to twelve times now so, i don't think she is. as for th consumption, it would be very unlikely she would have survived, but we can just pertend. I liked it. |
 Marcie Gore 1/1/02 . chapter 9Great Story Thanks for the happy ending. I just saw MR, Loved the movie but Hated the ending. Wanted Them to live Happyly ever After. TUbrulois AKA, Consumptionn is Curable NOW, but not sure WHen the Treatments were dicovered But as you said In That World anything is possible. Well done |
 marysa 1/1/02 . chapter 9 BRAVO! GREAT STORY! |
 Pim 1/1/02 . chapter 9 First of all, I really enjoyed your story. I didnt even think about all the little unimportant things in here that everyone else is dwelling on. I think that its really dumb for them to point out stuff like that, its a fanfic, it isnt suppose to be perfect. And as for those people complainging about the spoilers and stuff, well, your dumb.. when you read fanfics about movies you havent seen yet, its gonna spoil the movie, because the fanfic is based on the movie.. its common sense. So please, just give this author the credit she deserves because this is a great story. |
 Amber Starr 1/1/02 . chapter 1I love Moulin Rouge very much, and like your story. Although I love the real ending much more, the tragic romance, I like yours. The only thing is you should keep the characters true to who they truley are. But it's a pretty good story, a little predictible, but good none the less! |
 Brynnjermin 1/1/02 . chapter 9 I must agree with your last comment. People were picking bits out of my story like that. This story was wonderful. You did an awesome job.. I hope that I will be able to write just as well as you. Agian good job i quite enjoyed reading it. |
 Brynnjermin 1/1/02 . chapter 6 This is wonderful so far... I wasnt going to review till the end but I love that song and the way you putit in here was extreamly funny. This is great so far! |
 unknown 1/1/02 . chapter 9 Great story. But about the Married Marie to Zidler is NOT true. I've seen the Movie 11 times in the theatre and I did not hear madame Zidler, I heard Mosure (can't spell french that well) Zidler and the translation to that is Mr. Zidler plus I own the DVD and the VCD. Great story. |
 Lindy OLeary 12/26/01 . chapter 8I really like the story except I have a few suggestions you can make:
1)Make the chapters longer.. Expand upon it more, give it more depth...
2)In the movie, Marie IS married to Zidler.
It is very good it just to be more accurate. Because Satine can't just recover from Consumption or known as tuberculosis... Back in the 1900 there was no cure for tuberculosis at that time. And when Satine blushed, remember she is a courtesan and is used to men being around her...
Please continue by the way, and a good start! |
 Ezzy 12/20/01 . chapter 8 WHY DID YOU STOP? THIS IS SO GREAT! I have seen the movie over a dozen times, obsessed, yeah that's me, but this story is just so great, don't stop especially now! It's not fair to leave us hanging like that! The duke comes in with a gun fires it, is really pissed and you stop! What's up with that! Continue continue please! |