Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Of All The Gorram Luck - Page 1 of 2
dragonlots
2007-10-08 . chapter 3
Hello,

Just found your story. Had fun so far reading it. Let you know more about I think later.
Chateaubriand ou rien
2007-02-26 . chapter 9
Woah, this crossover was pretty cool. I saw Firefly not so long ago, and I just finished the entire babylon 5 run last week, and all the voices were okay in my head. It was a great reading.

Ho, and about what you said about the flamer. As painful as it can be to say for a trekkie like me... Babylon 5 IS INDEED the greatest Sci-Fi use ever of the television medium.
garden-crafter
2006-10-03 . chapter 7
Great idea to have River wave her hands through Draal's projection -- very funny !
garden-crafter
2006-10-03 . chapter 4
Kosh's comment about "They do not belong here" seems to suggest that Serenity is currently in the B5 'verse.

Now that you've mentioned it, Book with his hair sticking out all bushy (like when he scared River) COULD possibly be mistaken for a Centauri with a human hair-style.

It's VERY funny how the crew thinks that the aliens are humans in costumes who are wearing masks.
garden-crafter
2006-10-03 . chapter 3
there might have been a rift in space, that Serenity crossed just before they met the ship that they followed to B5
garden-crafter
2006-10-03 . chapter 2
great red herring, that the name of Mal's home planet would be so similar to the name of an evil from the Babylon 5 'verse.
garden-crafter
2006-10-03 . chapter 1
I've never seen a firefly/babylon 5 crossover before ... but it looks interesting and I'm curious to see where you take it.
Lauren Hedgehog
2006-09-28 . chapter 9
Oh :-) I really liked it :-) It's true that you may need a little work on the length, but I found the story to be exciting and original. I absolutely love both series :-)

A note in regard to flames - If people can't even write a grammatically correct sentence, then I wouldn't be overally worried about their opinion on your story ;-) I think you did a great job :-)
Hilary Weston
2006-09-23 . chapter 9
Not bad. It's just a shame it was so short; a story of four thousand words I would have in just one segment (my average length for a chapter is three thousand). I felt I was just getting into it, and it stopped.
tHe EsChAtOnIc HeReTiC
2006-09-21 . chapter 9
And you call yerself an "Author"? This midget-sized ouvbre doens't stand to its potential! Get out of this forum ye wyrd being! And kill yourself after that!
tHe ReAl AdMiRaL hErEtIc
2006-09-19 . chapter 7
Ejem, mister. Why are you ** the good image of b5 with such a **-spawned show as Serenity? Better stop here or I'll show you personally a honest "Gorram" act of God!
Alison M. DOBELL
2006-09-15 . chapter 5
I was so looking forward to reading a Firefly/Babylon 5 crossover so was disappointed that the characters for both shows didn't sound right, Captain Reynolds never refers to his crew as hands and Keffer talking about Babylon 5 the way he did would have made any smart person turn and run as fast as they could in the opposite direction. And Lennier did not learn Mandarin Chinese to help Garibaldi assemble the motorbike, it was Japanese. The only two who came across well were River and Kosh. Keffer's description of Serenity when he first sees the Firefly was nothing like the ship. Such a disappointment as I love both shows passionately. Hope if you decide to write more you will study the characters before trying to depict them. I wasn't going to say anything then considered that you might appreciate someone giving you an honest opinion. None of my comments are intended to offend.
Julie
2006-09-14 . chapter 4
AGH! Not a cliffhanger!! NO! Please write more soon! I'm really enjoying this story.
Julie
2006-09-14 . chapter 3
I like how you've let each group is reaching erroneous conclusions about each other! It is very much in character with the tv shows. Also, how the Firefly group aren't aware there are aliens right away, even when seeing them. Likewise, that the B5 characters are so used to aliens that it never occurs to them that these new humans might never have seen one. Very cool!
Julie
2006-09-14 . chapter 2
I like that you are keeping each of the tv shows as their own separate universes. And using Sector 14 to do it adds to the mystery. Getting the suspicions up of the B5 characters by revealing Mal's home planet's name is certainly going to give the plot some fun. I'm always disappointed in other crossovers that start out with both sides completely trusting the other - much to unrealistic. This story is coming along great!
Return to Top