 Shadowmaiden3 2009-05-17 . chapter 2oh jeez, I'm sad it's complete, I really enjoyed this because the ending on Pt. Gate really didn't satisfy me. Thank you!
PS, you do Barty (couldn't help myself) really well, right down to the footnotes. |
 singing4ever11 2009-04-10 . chapter 2aw
this was so cute!
i loved bart's chaper. the footnotes were def. somethig he'd say.
keep writing
~S4E |
 hikaru takaya 2008-04-29 . chapter 2i'm interested in how this is going to turn out!! keep it going!! |
 Mysterious Sapphire Butterfly 2007-07-05 . chapter 2ur story rocks! its almost as though jonathan stroud is writin! u rock! |
 Billie the fourth sage 2007-05-11 . chapter 2What a wonderful epilogue! Couldn't have written it better. Okay, maybe I could've but I didn't so, I hope you update! whee, evil Bart! |
 Thunderstorm101 2007-03-28 . chapter 2I can definitely see John Mandrake dieing completely here. Death to Mandrake! Long live Nathanial!
Update, pretty please? This is good! |
 Oneaka 2007-03-26 . chapter 2i love this book. i also think that Nathaniel shouldn't have died. i like your fanfic. good job |
 Alice-In-Wonderland101 2007-03-25 . chapter 2Mwahahaha you must update! And I love that you put in the footnotes like in the book! |
 Trinny 2006-12-29 . chapter 2Please update more! You write very well in character, but it was very irksome reading 'Nathanial' instead of 'Nathaniel.' IN further chapters you should change this |
 Solarengo 2006-12-18 . chapter 2Great job. I really like the fact that Nathaniel is still alive. Really like that fact. Really do. |
 Moonstar of FireClan 2006-11-29 . chapter 2I LOVE IT! it's so well written, it seems like it could really be the last two chapters. I'd love it if you did a fourth book, based on what you have written here. it would be amazing :) |
 zippingzephyr 2006-11-26 . chapter 2I really like what you've done here. It's really funny! I also like the take on everyone's personality...you make them all interesting and funny. Good job! Please update soon!
Btw, Happy Holidays! |
 Minish Link 2006-11-09 . chapter 2not bad. make sure to write more. |
 ailiricxxz 2006-10-08 . chapter 2really nice story! please continue. although, could you please spell out the names instead of just writing Ms P? hahax!! cant wait!! xD |
 MixedUpAgain 2006-10-06 . chapter 2please continue! |