Wow. That was a very sad story I almost cried. My guess that the person who told the story was Knuckles because he mentioned when he goes back to Angel Island.

Hey! I figured it out! Its...dadadaDA...KNUCKLES! ) yayknux (

KNUCKLES! It's Knuckles!

KNUCKLLLLLES!

I had 2 guesses

1:silver(dude, he can poick up a pick up without even touching it, technicly making him the strongest sonic the hedgehog charecter)

2:knuckles

It,s knuckles! he,s so sweet.

Very sad. Let's hope this convinces both Tails and Eggman to work on cures for incurable diseases so that this doesn't have to happen again. I'm guessing you picked Cream because she would have been the least complaining at the end. Nice job.

KNUCKLES! MAN THAT WAS SAD! HOW DID CREAM DIE IN THE FIRST PLACE? NICE STORY THOUGH! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!

Aw... I cried at the end.

At first when Cream chose the person cause he was lonley my guesses were Shadow and Knuckles, then I thought that Knux might know the constellations better than Shad, and during the "Despite my strenth" part I pretty much knew.

Anyway... wonderful story! And I loved the alteration of Twinkle at the end.

It's Ciel! I think...I'm pretty sure it's Ciel cuz Gemini is in love with Tikal and stargazing with Cream sounds like something Ciel would do and I think I remember reading that Ciel got married to Cream or something...

Aw...how sad! I thought it was either Cheese or Tails, but I never would've guess it was Knuckles.

Nice job. Very touching.

Aiko-Chan SoT

Wonderful. I wish I could write sad, emotional, things like this. Short, sweet, and touching.

(Crying uncontrollably)WAH!

That sucks. Cream dying,not the story.

Man Cream's my fav girl char.

Good story. Really sad. And the nursery rhyme only made it sadder.

Oh...it's obviously Kunckles...or Tikal,but she's dead.

Lucky, she gets to see Cream again.

(resumes crying)

it's i bet why you wonder cause his name was never mentioned not in one way through the course of the story and you kinda gave it away with "when i go back to angel island..." but anyway sad but good story make sure you update brotherhood again soon plz

This story was great. It's so sad, I almost cried. It's Knuckles right?