|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| Lady Ariez 2007-12-30 ch 7, | abuseI want more! |
| dragondreamer99 2007-10-26 ch 7, | abusewow... i am so glad i read this (although im sure i would have done eventaully anyway lol) - that was really amazing, all of your others are as well of course but for some reason this one seemed different, a lot deeper (and i nearly cried near the end, terrific idea and incredibly well-written ^-^) -- and i see your point too btw, if (or hopefully when ^^) i do get around to writing about frodo leaving and meeting arminas again (if thats still ok ^^) i'll keep this fic in mind so hopefully it makes a bit of sense ^-^ -- thankyou so much for the inspiration and the really beautiful fic, you really outdid yourself with this one ^-^ ~have fun... always ^-^ |
| Miss Quartermain 2007-05-14 ch 1, | abuseThis is so cute! I've always wondered what would happen to Bilbo and Frodo after leaving Middle-earth. |
| Elena maiden of Gondor 2007-02-24 ch 7, | abusethis was a wonderfull story. celebrimbor is now my new favorite elf. i too ached for him when he had to give up the rings. i'm adding this story to my favorties. |
| lovethosehobbits 2006-11-29 ch 7, anon. | abuseJust lovely. Written with such a soft, lyrical tenor...I felt such peace for Frodo and everyone else. Well done, love. |
| Caet Rae 2006-11-29 ch 7, | abuseThis was a very touching story. I'm glad I took the time to read it. Cheers. -Caet |
| lovenhope 2006-11-29 ch 7, | abuseThis was really sweet chapter especially when elrond and his mother reunite after so very long. |
| Mala Suerte 2006-11-29 ch 7, | abuseAck! It's over! Darn, I loved all of your stories to date. It's always sad when one is over. I especially liked the "Quarantined" series. Congratulations on finishing another one! |
| StarofElendil 2006-11-28 ch 7, | abuseHurrah! But does END mean end of story or end of chapter? Please let it mean end of chapter! |
| jules14 2006-11-28 ch 7, | abuseThat's it? That's the end? What a shame; I was hoping it would go on longer! Still, I suppose all good things come to an end at last. It is still one of my favorite stories: so beautiful it almost made me cry. Thank you for writing it. |
| Noldo wise 2006-11-28 ch 7, | abuseI don't belive its over...:( Sequel please! I'm happy that this got updated! |
| sentarla 2006-11-28 ch 7, | abuseoh, the end... I really liked that story, it was peacful and I would really like to see more of Mellon. PLease write a sequel sentarla |
| Anargil 2006-11-28 ch 7, | abuseI forgot to review the chapter before this one!! I feel so stupid! So you're getting a double review this time, whether you like it or not. :) Both chapters were really great, I can't believe the story's over! Though the end was very fitting, it came too fast for me. I wish it could go on and on and on... However, this does bring one happy aspect to mind... pretty soon there will be a new story I can sink my teeth into! Frodo: *sigh* That really was beautiful, Shirebound. I look forward to reading more of your work. Though... *glances sideways at Anargil* perhaps not as rabidly as some! Anargil ^_~ |
| StarofElendil 2006-11-18 ch 6, | abuseAs ever, eagerly awaiting updates. Nice job! Not to give anything away, but is "she" Varda? I only just began reading the Silmarillion... |
| Frodo Freak2 2006-11-17 ch 6, | abuseI just get a smile on my face when I think of an excited Elrond. :) |