WOW! WOW! WOW!
THis fic is amazing! I loved that the story mainly focused on Logan's feelings and points of view on their situation and relationship as most fics seem to focus on the feelings of the female in the story (ie Rory) so it was really refreshing to have it mainly the males POV.

The flashbacks of how they met were great, so cute. Chapter 14 made me cry so much as did the epilogue, Honor dying was so sad but also had a bittersweet feeling about it as it ultimately resulted in Rory and Logan getting together properly.

I just read your story and I love it! It was so good, and actually had a good plot that had ups and downs, ending in a very good epilogue. I loved how it ended. You did a good job with the epilogue. You ended things great.

i just cried because that was so good.

Wow! I've been sick in bed for a few days now & decided to find a story I hadn't read before and settled on this one. I'd read a few chapters here & there but never really got into it-- I must have been crazy. I loved this story! It was amazing, the way you write about friendship and family was perfect. And Logan reading Honor's book, the whole ending, was exactly what this story needed. I'm sorry I missed this the first time around, but glad I caught it now!

First of all I´ve got to tell you: You are mean! You made me cry like a little girl since the momente Honor died til he end of the story. But I also got to tell that this was one of the best fics I ever read, if not the best. I was funny, and cute and sad... and for some reason I loved It!!
I loved all the running through New York answering clues at the beggining and all the movie references (By the way chosing 'When Harry mett Sally' for the movie night wasn't just a coincidence, was it?) And most of all I love the fact that it was never predictable... I don't know it's just when you read much fics they all somehow start to loke the same and the way Logan and Rory end up being togeter is usually predictable well in this case it wasn't, and I loved it!
oh and please excuse me if I made any grammar mistakes, I'm Brasiliam so that's my excuse huahauhuh
bye...

FANTASTIC story!

I LOVE THIS STORY! You just have such an amazing writing style, i just love it. I'm slowly making my way through all your fanfics for Gilmore Girls.
Well done on yet another fantastic gg fanfic!

This is the best gilmore girls
Fanfic I have ever read
I LOVED it :)

Wow! That was such a good story! it was really sad too. i was balling by the end.

i love thus story it's amazing!!

I liked it, it was touching in a weird sort of way, Honor's death was nessasary I guess, but that doesn't stop it from being sad.

Liked the whole "Happy Tree/Happy Forest" metaphor, very funny.

This is so amazing-I literally teared up in the epilogue. Thank you so much and I hope you continue using your writing talent!

I know this story was finished in September, but I *had* to tell you how much I absolutely loved it. I'm fairly certain it is now my favorite fanfic that I've ever read--any category, any genre, any pairing. You've written an extremely well-crafted story here; I really appreciate a fanfic author who knows how to tell a good tale and give characters life and depth beyond the sometimes-limited portraits we see in the original stories. And then, more than even just the solid construction of the story arc, you have clear, interesting prose. (I love the balance of description and dialogue--your descriptions are well-written and we need them, but you remember that it's TV fanfic and what we really want in this type of story is dialogue!) Good job transitioning from the wit and banter of the first chunk of the story to the angst and character growth of the latter part, as well. Really my only complaint would be the occasional grammatic/syntactic blip and a few places where you got repetitive, but even those are admirably rare, *especially* for a piece of fanfic. :P So, all that is just to say very, *very* well done and thank you for an extraordinarily enjoyable fanfic experience. ~SuzieQ57

So I thoroughly enjoyed this story. It made me smile. It made me laugh. It made me cry. It made me angry. It made me happy. It made me content. Haha. As far as the angry comment goes I often feel like people are too hard on you. Haha. I thought you wrote ten year olds pretty well. I would think that no you didn't write the average ten year old but you did write a pretty good version of how those four would have been at ten. Anyway I was very impressed and I loved it. I hope your exams well okay. I read in one of your stories that you had to take very important and expensive vet exams so I hope you did well. I'll end it with a short, sweet, and simple marvelous dahling, simply marvelous.

Wow...
I just started reading this story yesteday, and I have to say it...I loved it.
This was such a good story, I can't even describe it.
When you had them drunk, I practically felt a little tipsy myself, lol.
And when Honor died, my heart broke.
I loved this story completely.
You're a very talented writer.
Keep up the good work!