Woah, that was great! I like the way that, though Harry was pursuaded by Hermione in the end (or at least leaned that way), the reader didn't have to be; they could've stuck by Ron (which I did). I really liked it, and the Harry/Ginny at the end was nice without being overwhelming. Wonderful!

oh my gosh! i read this story forever ago but i couldnt find! you do a great job and since i read this, i really believe that remus and sirius were together. i also really like how you connected them to ron and hermione!

Hehehe!
I loved your fic.
I read it ages ago, and I spent hours trying to find it again and then one day it just popped up in a random thing I was reading!
=] I was so excited!

Wow, what I thought was going to be a commonplace fic about the HP youngsters arguing about the Infamous Sirius and Remus Friend/Lover relationship thing, but you suprised me! So intricate and detailed, every argument, some old but a few new, worked and completed the image you(and Hermione) wanted to portray. Good job and good luck on all your other fan fiction.

wow...
I've never liked a story so much that contains a ship that I don't support.
You write magnificent, and allthough I find it hard to belive they would have been together (hell, I even am a fanatic Tonks-Remus shipper) I loved the links you make between Ron and Hermione...It was a classic discussion between those two!

x-mokimik-x

an interesting thought… and for some strange reason it makes sense when you put it that way I suppose.. haven’t really thought of it like that

A discussion very Canon on Sirius/Lupin!...
very original... strange, but interesting...
Please keep writting...