I can totally see Sam doing that to Dean. Great story!!

LOL! Too cute!;)

I really love this story. It's gotta be like the fourth time I've come back and read it :)
Greek wrap...ew...

Hah, great! I was wondering about that raincheck, actually. If he ever used it. :p

OMG. I laughed so hard I nearly had tears running down my face. Totally priceless. I absolutely freaking loved this. I would love to see Sam catch Dean off guard on the show. I think it would be incredibly funny!

I'm glad you gave Sam the chance to use that raincheck! I was wondering if it would come up in the final episodes but Sam was too busy dying I guess. Sniff. Anyway, great oneshot!!

lol awesome

Now that's the raincheck we've all been waiting for.

Brilliantly done.

LOL

It was awesome and hilarious and cute. :D

Cute!

LOL! That was funny as hell! Especially imagining Dean with jelly on his face.

That was cute, and awesome! Great job, I loved it!

Oh my God that's a weird family dynamic. And yet...

You captured the boys perfectly! Well done, well done, twelve cream-filled donuts to you for the sheer brilliance! I'm in awe. *awed*

No sooner had a fan friend said she'd love to see Sam claim his raincheck, that I read this fic of yours and passed it quickly on. I had thought of writing one myself, but you did it so perfectly, there's no need. I love the random little banter of sandwiches-- trust Sam to wonder about the whys of a gas station wrap--and how the punch comes out of the blue for us as much as it does for Dean. And Sam's reason: he wanted to see jelly smeared over Dean's face. And that he's brought ice, too, because he's still a good little brother. Great details, very enjoyable, thanks.

::giggle:: i really want the show to follow up on sams's raincheck... but i doubt they'll manage to be as funny as your version