Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Help
Reviews For: The Tenant from Staddle - Reviews: Page 1 of 3
Jade 2008-10-15 . chapter 36
more, more, MORE!
JennieM 2008-10-13 . chapter 1
This post-LOTR story is well-written, believable, with a decent plot, and the characters are strongly based on what JRRT wrote, making it a very refreshing change from the Aragorn/Legolas slash or the 'girl finds herself in Middle Earth' kind of story.

I think that one of the strengths of this tale is that the Hobbit characters are hobbit-like, and the character from Minas Tirith has had to go through a steep learning curve.

Also, the cousins, the Bracegirdles are very hobbit-like in their development.

The major flaw in this is that it hasn't been updated for some time, and I should like it to be.
Worldwalker Pure 2008-08-27 . chapter 27
I am quite enjoying this story; it's fairly rare to find a drama story that actually understands how drama works in my usual fandoms. I offer you my thanks for crafting a story that is both lively and compelling.
JennieM 2008-08-20 . chapter 1
I'm enjoying this, and hope there will be some more soon.
Tracey Claybon 2008-08-04 . chapter 36
Wow - what a wedding - and it's wonderful how all the presents coordinated so very well.

Loved the chapter... and you included everyone!
szepilona10 2008-08-04 . chapter 36
Smoked goose?! They are soo lucky! You're making me hungry for goose! Great chapter! Update soon please!
God Bless!

~Szepilona10~

Ps: I think that you should write a story about Hurin(or someone else) becoming something like a diplomat(sp?) to Arnor.
szepilona10 2008-07-13 . chapter 35
Great chapter! Update soon please!
God Bless!

~Szepilona10~
szepilona10 2008-06-04 . chapter 13
The thought of trees growing in Mordor is so happy I could cry!
God Bless!

~Szepilona10~
szepilona10 2008-04-13 . chapter 34
Great chapter! I am trying to imagin(sp?) the table shawl. It must be beutiful(sp?)! Update soon please!

~Szepilona10~
szepilona10 2008-04-02 . chapter 33
Nice chapter! Update soon please!

~Szepilona10~
jpdt19 2008-04-02 . chapter 33
Excellent. Thanks!
szepilona10 2008-03-06 . chapter 32
Great story! I really like it, because there are a lot of rangers in it. It's very funny to me when they all call Aragorn their "Lord Cousin".
Primsong 2008-03-03 . chapter 1
I've only just found this tale and am already fascinated with what you are doing with the viewpoint of the other hobbits of the Shire in that time. I haven't a lot of time to read, but I hope I will be able to continue this one and am looking forward to it - your writing is well researched and descriptive without coming across as stilted - nicely done.
jpdt19 2008-03-01 . chapter 32
Very nice, thanks for carrying on with this.
jpdt19 2008-01-18 . chapter 31
Superb, delighted to see an update on this story.
A cursed catapult stone, ouch, sounds nasty.
I loved this chapter especially, i always love poking around in old buildings, delightfully done. Really got me interested. They might find armouries perhaps, but it's probably been looted i suppose long ago.
Return to Top