Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Brothers in Arms - Page 1 of 2
Medieval Liz
2009-06-01 . chapter 1
Oh wow! I just found this fantastic story and can I just say, again, Wow! Brilliant! I'd love to read it from Scott's POV... now I'll just have to check out the rest of your stories to see if it's there! lol Great story!
spinningleaves
2008-12-08 . chapter 1
I love it! The idea of the picture comparisons at the end was excellent! I liked how the story was told only from Virgil's perspective instead of adding little bits from Scott's view. It kept the suspense up!
Professor Ali
2008-11-08 . chapter 1
Hi again Purupuss,
This had to be the next story of yours to be reviewed. Sorry it has take a while for me to get around to it. I would like to be able to say that it is your best, but I can’t say that yet because, as I’ve told you – I’ve yet to get through all of them!! you have been a very prolific writer on this site.
I have read and reread this one, it really caught my imagination. I wonder if you are proud of this story? You should be – I think it is masterful. I love pre- IR stories, and this one serves several really great purposes – it answers a question that I often wondered about, and provides a wonderful opportunity to explore how the various characters would react to this very unusual situation. I howled with laughter at Jeff’s initial response to Kyrano’s suggestion! I’m a bit of a John and Gordon fan, and I enjoyed Gordon arriving, looking un-Gordon like, and then being ticked off by Grandma! I also think you were quite right about Gordon’s reaction – his openness and acceptance are perfectly in character. You have written John beautifully I think, the way that although he may not truly understand the facts – they are facts nonetheless and he can’t ignore them. The scenes in the incident room are very good. I would almost think that you have some military connections. I love the NZ connection of course!
What does all this amount to? A difficult subject, handled excellently – and best of all, you have left it to the reader to make up his or her own mind. I know what I believe...
Ali
McHammy
2008-11-04 . chapter 1
Another superb story Purupuss.

“We’ll have dinner at my place. I’ll cook you something.”
Scott laughed. “Please, Virg. I’ve just escaped death once. Don’t ask me to do it again.”

Classic!!
tiylaya
2008-10-17 . chapter 1
Brilliant story! I loved the way the bond between the two of them manifested, and the way the evidence for it steadily accumulated. I very much enjoyed reading this - thank you!
Little Miss Bump
2008-07-08 . chapter 1
Wow! This was fantastic! The way that you sculpted John, Scott and Virgil's characters was so wonderful! And I'm glad that Scott wasn't too badly hurt, and that Virgil only had an infection, not brain damage. The idea to make Virgil draw the photos was so original and unique, I loved it! A really great story!
dragon shadows
2007-11-06 . chapter 1
i liked that, thanks
brezo-1816
2007-05-08 . chapter 1
This was an excellent story. The empathetic link between Scott and Virgil was something really unique and yet so perfect for the pair.

If you do a storyline as unique and complex as this there's always a risk that you sort of lose touch with the characters and the little traits that make them who they are but (much to my relief) you didn't do that. You made sure you kept the character's personalities right on target and that's one of the reason's that made me love this story. The other reason is that I like when there's a close bond between Scott and Virgil because I've always seen them as the closest of the five Tracy brothers.

Love the story. Great job
Olivia Sutton
2007-02-11 . chapter 1
HI,

I loved this! A telepathic link between Scott and Virgil? You simply MUST do more with the idea!
Excellent!

--Olivia
jendarra
2006-11-15 . chapter 1
Have jsut found this.

And loved it.

This made to family so real. Always knew there was something special between Scott and virgil.

Don't make me wait ninety yearss for more.
Claudette
2006-11-10 . chapter 1
Wonderful story Purupuss. I really enjoyed reading this. I loved the way you so clearly drew the characters - the people we know & love were all there, with the indications of the future to come.

One thing I don't understand - how did he suddenly end up with an infection in his arm? Infections don't just happen, something causes them. Was it an abscess? I would have thought any prior injury would have been commented upon during the events but there is no hint of anything possibly being wrong. A psycosomatic infection perhaps?

Anyway, great story - again.
sky's girl forever
2006-11-06 . chapter 1
YAY! I Scott/Virg Special link! I love it! There just so cute. lol
Ms Hobgoblin
2006-11-03 . chapter 1
Wow! What an awesome story, I'm glad you decided to put it on paper (or computer!). Very cool idea, and the reactions of all the characters were great! I was hooked from the first paragraph.
Hob x
ejb
2006-11-03 . chapter 1
I knew this had been posted but wanted to read it when I had the time to give it my full attention without any interruptions. What a great story about the family and their lives before International Rescue was up and running. I thoroughly enjoyed it and could not help notice that John was interested in reading about 'Ursine species of Arctic polar life.' A premonition of things to come perhaps?

Well done, another great story from you as always.
ms. imagine
2006-11-03 . chapter 1
Once I started reading, I simply couldn't stop until I got to the end. Such an engrossing story!

I just love how you wrote the characters - it was so nice to read about them in their former careers and situations, but they're still the Tracys we know and love. I have the image of Gordon 'scruffing down' and dumping his uniform stuck firmly in my head. Oh, and fantastic treatment of the relationships within the family!

The technology and politics of this (slightly) future world were perfectly natural and believable. All the military lingo was awesome and I loved how they all sniped about the other services. (I had a good laugh when no one wanted to discuss the merits of the Army :D)

I really enjoyed reading this, and it's so nice to see a story that so realistically explores the lives of the Tracys before IR - particularly the mystery of Scott's shiny medal. Thanks for sharing it :)
Return to Top