 verity candor 9/1/09 . chapter 1Haha. Nice job with Fudge here. I am impressed! |
 magdilen 5/22/09 . chapter 1Good job. I love how he is so calm. |
 clap your hands say claire 11/27/07 . chapter 1Ah ... It's like the missing chapter of Prisoner of Azkaban ... |
 Purveyors of Aids 10/3/07 . chapter 1Ooh, very interesting. |
 the lycans 8/10/07 . chapter 1a very interesting take on Sirius. no quill or pen. Never thought about that particualar problem. goes to my favs. |
 Seer of Spots 2/12/06 . chapter 1I'm writing something akin to this; some of Sirius' memories...
Nice work. |
 Rubber-duckiesofdoom 2/14/05 . chapter 1decent. Not your best, but it would seem that it's also your first, so whatever. |
 Talamh 4/10/04 . chapter 1Interesting PoV and brilliantly described as well. _ Loved the last line - I'll bet not many people thought of that when they read PoA! _ Loking forward to reading more of your work.
Talamh |
 RavenLady 5/8/02 . chapter 1Wow. I really like this! I really, really like this. Very well written. |
 Aille 3/7/02 . chapter 1You know, I think it would un-nerve me too if I thought someone was supposed to be nuts, and they talked to me normally. |
 Starlit Me 2/23/02 . chapter 1 Nicely written (although you have some spelling errors). I liked this fic because it is not something everyone is writing about. |
 Experimental-Eye 1/20/02 . chapter 1 "I was so unstrung by my exchange with Sirius Black I was halfway across the water when I wondered how, with no quill or pen, he would fill a crossword puzzle out."
You know that thought never entered my mind... so when I saw it I sat thinking... what? ..
::rolls eyes:: Of course! Azkaban with it's quill shop so prisoners can do crosswords!
Anyway...
I loved how you portrayed Fudge... very realistic... |
 Morbane 1/15/02 . chapter 1Not many people can effectively portray a character like Fudge. Well done! What's really good is the way you stay completely out of the POV of anyone else, which I'd think would be a real temptation in this case. This piece is short, succinct, well managed and superbly crafted. Only the part:
'I laughed, hardly understanding why Black was affecting me so. *He truly must be You-Know-Who's right hand*, I thought; *how else could he be so normal*'
seemed a little forced. Enthralling.
:D Morbane |
 Crystalite 104 12/21/01 . chapter 1That's a POV ya don't see every day... Quite good. |
 irisbleufic 9/23/01 . chapter 1You thrill me! |