 Potgenie 4/17/05 . chapter 1GREAT FIC! |
 arokh 7/23/03 . chapter 1 that was cool i liked it you should i dunno continue! |
 Only Human 6/14/03 . chapter 1Good chapter, I'm impressed. Good idea on the line about near misses. Very good indeed. Keep it up. |
 Myrtle 10/8/02 . chapter 1I think I've read this before, but I'll review it anyway.
It's really good, though perhaps (if possible) more Remus would make a GREAT improvement (I always say that to everyone!)
:-) |
 An Anti-Sheep Cheese Muffin 9/2/02 . chapter 1that was so sweet and cute, i enjoyed that very much keep up w/the writing! |
 RavenLady who's having problems signing in for some reason 5/9/02 . chapter 1 This is just too cute for words! |
 Crystalite 104 1/5/02 . chapter 1She was lucky, that's for sure. |
 bluemeanies 9/3/01 . chapter 1once again very good. Poor book, and poor maruders. |
 Madhuri 7/24/01 . chapter 1I looked at the summary and thought 'Cool! A Forbidden Forest fic!'. But, really, this is *so* much more. For a short story, it really moved me. Your style of writing is incredible, and your descriptions hauned me. The whole story seems to move in a blurry, dreamlike pace (especially the scene in the Forest), which is extremely cool. You've got what we know of MWPP down pat. Only a slight nitpick... Bertha Jorkins was a couple of years older than the Marauders. Great job! |
 Episcopal Witch 7/17/01 . chapter 1GREAT STORY! Very original idea and the characters all spot-on. Lily is delightfully spunky. I love fill-in-the-cracks stories, and that statement of Lupin's about the "near misses" has intrigued me since I read PoA. |
 Pigwidgeon 7/16/01 . chapter 1 Wow... |
 Fire Lizid 7/15/01 . chapter 1aaaaaaaaaaaaaaw... I like the lion... And I'm guessing that Remus was the werewolf and James was the Stag? |
 Sierra Charm 6/24/01 . chapter 1Ah! Good, great, wonderful, how many ways can I say it? I LOVED THIS STORY! _ This was really good, it's going on my faves, i'm really hyper, and keep writing! _ |
 Kitty-Cat1286 6/20/01 . chapter 1Neat. |
 Naraku 6/20/01 . chapter 1Very nice... I liked the interaction between the characters, especially between Remus and Lily. The scene where Prongs saves Lily was very well done, and I especially liked the part where Lily reached out to touch him... very reminiscent of Harry and his Patronus in PoA. (I also liked the Gryffindor mascot- I want one! :) |