Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: You Were All I had
NewMoonFlicker
2007-12-23 . chapter 1
O.o I don't believe it... I've spent over two hours online and this is the first story I've found that does NOT involve ELRICEST?! Thank heaven! I was beginning to go nuts!

This part of the story is a bit closer to my heart at the moment - a friend of mine just finished the series and the movie two days ago and it's still fresh in my mind. The ending is incredible and heck yeah I agree with you, I don't believe that Edward would have died instantly. The most effective way to kill someone instantly is to aim through the - wait, I'd better not get into that. :) And it's ED, some people don't die easily and he's not weak in mind or body. Gah, I shudder to think what must have been going through his mind and Al's as well... I'm very interested in what you come up with! What I've read is really quite good. Please continue!

AND THANK YOU FOR NOT SCREWING UP THEIR RELATIONSHIP! :D
JellicleJosie
2007-06-10 . chapter 1
aww. so sad. nicely put very nicely put. ITS A MERICAL!! somebody actually made a fanfic that didnt make edward gay for roy! YOUR MY HERO!!
Legendary Chimera
2007-06-06 . chapter 1
Damn...am speechless. *favs*
ViolentImpulses
2007-05-09 . chapter 1
D'8> you made his death sound so painful! I LOVE IT! fave!
feefee223
2007-04-13 . chapter 1
its sad you have ed all ready condenming himself to hell...thats sad but very describtive ^^
Kaiho Inutaime
2007-04-06 . chapter 1
Aw! No!
This was GREAT! I loved it!! It was very sad and touching...:'(
GreedyGreed
2007-04-06 . chapter 1
Despite I've never seen the anime, I can say this is a very good fic
MilesTailsPrower-007
2007-04-05 . chapter 1
B- brotherhood! *flails like an idiot*

Okay. Now that that's out of the way, you did a super job. It was really heart-wrenching. The death was sort of frighteningly accurate, too, especially for someone who's obviously never experienced death before. (In this case, me.) What makes it striking is the fact that obviously -you've- never died either, and yet that seemed so eerily accurate.

Very well written. I like how you managed to stuff Al in there, even if his general presence in the story is limited here. Nice job!
High Elf
2007-02-25 . chapter 1
I've only recently become a fan of FMA so it has taken me awhile to find this story, but it was very well done, the interaction between the two brothers at the end was very touching. I also wanted to say good on you for the note at the beginning of the story. I am just starting to find out how hard it is to find stories that deviate from that. Congrats
sparkyfma2000
2006-11-17 . chapter 1
*eyes wide* That was good. *blinks a few times* No that was great. *sniffles* One of the saddest episodes in the series and you nailed it! Write more! These are good!
Return to Top