I really liked this. Your charaterization of James is perfect, exactly as I picture him.

This story really shows off how important the Marauders' friendship is to Sirius. Especially since he just left his house they're pretty much the only family he has in his life. Now he sees the seriousness of The Prank, and he needs forgiveness if he's is to move on. The concept of The Circle is so significant. I have no idea how you come up with these things, but I thank you for sharing this with us.

Cliche.

Sirius seemed so sad! :( I feel so bad for him! Siri rocks! :)

Hey! This story was amazing with a capital A! ;D I felt so bad for Sirius, but I'm so glad that they accepter him again!
Lots of Love
MilyMB
P.S. I would love to see your account of Sirius running away from home, your an amazing writer!

Really, really wonderful. Gone was almost as good, but this was wonderful. I love the way you write Remus and James interacting. Goes to favs!
Aimael

Oh my God. This was beautiful. Seriously totally completely wonderful. Extremely well-written. And the plot was awesome too. This has been over-done, but your version is like the so right one. You actually had me in tears over the beautiful friendship between James and Sirius. You described it just as I've pictured it. And the ending was great, I loved that you didn't have them all hugging, but Remus just flicking his face. It was perfect, as everything else about this story. May be my all-time favourite Marauder story.

Aw much cuteness but a good emotional range too! Well done I'm very impressed!

I first read this ages ago...I'd forgotten how good it is!! Thanks, as always!

You have any idea how heart wrenching this is. Absolutely amazing. goes to my favs. Perfectly in character. Bravo!

"Gone" is wonderful. This is just as good. Best Marauders/Whomping Willow aftermath story ever.

Aww... That was really well done. Really!

I went ahead and read "Gone" first, which was also well done. It's nice to see "bad guys" in a different light from time to time.

But this was great. Thanks for writing.

wow!
that was amazing. I'm crying now!

Fantastic sequel! That was really a heartbreaking and heartwarming scene. I loved how you had Mrs. Potters candles make the circle and slowly each boy joined circle as they forgave Sirius.

Beautiful. I can easily imagine this being just the way it happened. Sequel?