Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Tolyg i Veth, Loyal to the End - Page 1 of 2
Silivren Tinu
2009-03-26 . chapter 14
Very beautiful, Cal! This is just perfect to tie up a series. I just love the //Yes. I can.// at the end. It's just so special when one can say something like that, when a part of one's life ends. :)
cairistiona7
2009-03-25 . chapter 14
Lovely verse... I've not read your poetry, not being a big fan of any kind of poetry, but now I see I will need to go back and read them all. This may have been Aragorn or Legolas, but it's timeless in its cry: have I done my best? Something all of us ask ourselves as we age.

Really well done.
estelcontar
2009-03-25 . chapter 14
That's a lovely poem, Cal. Congratulations.
Jedi Sapphire
2009-03-25 . chapter 14
I loved this! And I'm so sorry this series of poems is ending... I especially liked the last two verses. They say so much, so beautifully, in just the right words.
Roses of Sharon
2009-03-24 . chapter 14
oh dahling i love you.
and are you back from england already?
wow.
asdfjkl;
2008-12-31 . chapter 13
damn. those were good. a couple made me cry!

keep writing xD
lindahoyland
2007-09-01 . chapter 1
This is exactly what friendship means,well said !
Marchwriter
2007-06-17 . chapter 6
Astonishing. Beautifully touching and entrancing as the Mellon Chronicles themselves in lyric form.

And your elvish is beautifully formed as well.

I do not often read poetry since I'm more of a prose person myself but the elegance of your words and the stark imagery you put into it (as well as all the obvious care) makes it much more accessible to people who don't read poetry.

These are magnificent pieces of work and you are to be commended for them.

Best,

~The Lady of Light~
StarLight9
2007-05-07 . chapter 12
Ah, once again, so beautiful! You have captured the emotions perfectly!
Aimme
2007-03-26 . chapter 11
LOVE IT!! Just like all your other ones!!

-Aimme-
Arya
2007-03-25 . chapter 10
What you have written is beautiful, heartfelt, and meaningful. Few can symbolize the enduring love and loyalty of friendship as wonderfully as you have. Elen sila lumenn, omentielvo, mellon-nin!
StarLight9
2007-03-25 . chapter 11
Great poem, brilliantly captures Aragorn's uncertainly and Legolas' trust in him.
Kalisona
2007-03-25 . chapter 11
^.^ That was really, really good! How do you do it, mellon nin? I cannot write poetry for anything!! Anyway, it was fantastic! ;)
~Kali
StarLight9
2007-03-15 . chapter 10
This was the best poem so far (maybe because "Priceless Treasure" is my favorite of the stories). I loved it! Great work!
LaegelGreenleaf
2007-03-13 . chapter 9
I love the way you wrote this poem between father and son.

I always wondered, why Thranduil would let his only heir (If Legolas is truely the only heir) go with the fellowship? why didn't he choose one of his warriors? makes you wonder about that. That has been in the back of my mind ever so long.
Return to Top