 samcamstargate1 2009-03-24 . chapter 1great story, loved it! |
 NarcissaVenus 2008-05-27 . chapter 1This was really good. |
 GoldenFawkes 2008-02-29 . chapter 1Ugh, damn it; why'd she have to be Mrs. Turner? I don't like Will! |
 piewacket 2007-07-02 . chapter 1Okay, only the fact that this is so incredibly well witten allows me to forgive you for being so cruel to Norrington!
We'll have to agree to disagree about how he would have behaved with the strumpet. LOL
The name of the ship,HMS Penitence, is truly inspired. |
 Turning Pirate 2007-07-02 . chapter 1Congratulations! You and your fantastic story have been inaugurated into the "Pirates of the Caribbean FanFiction Hall of Fame".
Please visit my profile page for more details.
It's not as grand as it sounds, but we hope that by setting this up we are providing a valuable service for all PotC FanFiction lovers out there.
Please come and make some nominations of your own, share your wisdom or just join in the fun! |
 Christina Simon 2006-12-09 . chapter 1I really enjoyed this. I'm always up for a little illicit Elizbeth/Norrington, when I can find it! |
 JeanieBeanie33 2006-11-29 . chapter 1Expertly written. I especially liked the very end. |
 Astraeas Dreams 2006-11-29 . chapter 1Wow, a very good piece of work! I enjoyed reading it very much! Thank you!
Bye Astraeas Dreams |
 Katie 2006-11-29 . chapter 1 *gasp* That hussy!! First, she's engaged to Norrington, but she likes Will, then she breaks it off with Norrington and kisses Will, then they get engaged, then she starts to emotionally and psychically connect to Jack, then she starts to have these desires for him, then she makes out with him only to leave him to die and break his heart, and in the process, betrays Will, and now she married Will but is still friends with Jack and now she sexes up Norrington. That bitch. Great story. |
 sudoku 2006-11-29 . chapter 1Actually it is well written, I like the part when you contrast Norrington and the ship. I believe Elizabeth could do what she did although I am not sure about whether Norrington would do that, he could swing both ways (his characters in CotBP and DMC seem to be in opposite direction). Did you mean Norrington was ill-tempered? I thought he was a pretty calm and collected one, at least in CotBP. |
 BadLilBirdies 2006-11-29 . chapter 1I really, really like this story. But I'm wondering why they were approaching the Penitence with a white flag up in the first place. Beautifully written though. I like it alot. |