Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Chosen Destiny 2: The Guardian

spectre666
2007-08-14
ch 5,
abuseVery good. I like yor caharactization of Kim. Although I think she may be portrayed as taking a life with a little too much nonchalance. Or, is the "we're on 24/7. The slayer is taking over" theme her way of expressing heer doubts? The tweebs, would like to see first hand how they're doing. I can see the two budding Braniacs freexing their own clothes. LOL
Good job and looking forward to more.
HecatonchiresLM
2007-07-04
ch 4,
abuseStill cool. The Ron fight was well choreographed, as was the Faith on phone fight.

One nitpick -> rogue, not rouge(a type of makeup)
HecatonchiresLM
2007-06-20
ch 3,
abuseOoh! Wade's a demon! Shego is sarcastically cool! KP & Ron are on the outs with Global justice!
spectre666
2007-06-08
ch 3,
abuseGood story. Nice interpretation of Kim's stand offishness. Shyness rather than arogance. Very IC. Wade is a demon? And Ron doesn't know? Oh, forgot, no StD or Team Impossible, so they have never met face to face. This should be one heck of a curve. :P
Thanks,
Spectre
Balrog60
2007-06-08
ch 3,
abuseAs a combination of two of my favorite shows from over the years, I'm enjoying how you have woven them together so far. Pretty snappy dialogue and good action. Although I would have thought that Kim, as idealistic as she is usually depicted, might experience a bit more anguish over having to kill. Ron, a practical Smarty-Mart shopper, I can see achieving a balanced view of the carnage, just as he explains to Kim with the observations about the bloody demon. But I would expect Kim to keep pushing for non-lethal countermeasures, which could lead to Ron having to constantly 'clean up' after her. But what you have going here is great, so I'm not going to fret.

Enjoyed the scene in Dr. Director's office. The call to Ron's house was a nice touch. Are you letting Ron keep his Mystical Monkey Magic in this story-line? He appears to be almost as dangerous as Kim, but nothing has been attributed to the M3 yet, so I was just wondering.

Wade as demon is interesting. I can't see it as being much of a problem, at least directly, though. His friendship with Kim and Ron is too well established and we do have plenty of background material for the existence of 'good' or at least 'benign' demons in BTVS and Angel. His demonic heritage will give Kim and Ron a great contact point into the demonic world, but I can imagine that it could also cause problems for Kim's conscience, being presented with demons that do not have to be killed on sight. Again, could lead to questioning the need to kill in all battles, which could lead to hesitation and increased hazard. Just a thought.

Anyway, keep up the good work. If you keep writing it, I'll keep reading it.

Thanks,

Balrog60
HecatonchiresLM
2007-05-24
ch 2,
abusePlease, don't have abandoned this
Merklin
2007-04-19
ch 2,
abuseHey, popped over to read on this after reading the first one. Loved it, and loving this. Your writing style is good, and I love the cliffhanger, even if it is evil. Please update soon, I can't wait for the next chapter.
spectre666
2007-03-23
ch 1,
abuseSee the anonymous review. I don't know how that happened. If you are confused about the OC in my chap. 2 review I meant On Character.
Looking forward to your next.
Spectre
spectre666
2007-03-23
ch 2,
abuseI'm enjoying this. While so far, it's not quite as good as the original, it's still a fun piece. Very good fight scene. Kim's continueing questioning of killing is OC. The biggest problem I have is Will attempting to arrest them. I don't think murder or self defense is within his jurisdicition, and as the Major impied, they are on US soil. Will basically has no authority unless he is working through the local authorities. I refuse to believe even a fictitious US would allow the UN police powers within it's borders.
CajunBear73
2007-03-22
ch 2,
abuseWell, the Slayer side of Team Possible has done some work close to home. Will Du is out of the loop with this and his arrogance is about to get him in trouble again. So much ego, so little competence.

Later.

2006-12-08
ch 1, anon.
abuseDadnabbit, I know I reviewed this when it was first posted! I think you may have lost some in the "improvement" that FF is always attempting. I know I lost at least two from one story, "Season's Greetings". So, I'll attempt to reconstruct what I said then.
One, I like it. It shows great promise, with your usual flair for an interesting read. I realize it's a teaser, so it is going to be a little bare, but it really left me wanting more! The Wade conversation seemed too easy. Wade is a very realistic, logical, tech minded young man. I don't think he would accept vampires, demons, and hellions (OH,MY!) quite that readily. Other than that one small caviot, you have my attention. Please continue.
Thanks
Return to Top