Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: How the Grinch Saved Christmas - Page 1 of 4
Scarym
2009-12-15 . chapter 1
Thanks for a funny and sweet Christmas story. I thought it was so cute that Rodney had to entertain the children.

I like that Teyla help Rodney carry out his secret santa activities.
Calamitynexus
2009-09-24 . chapter 5
I really love your stories and your McKay. They are very well done and intersting. Your grasp of psychology and character is simply amazing.
Whirlwind421
2009-07-08 . chapter 5
Awesome story! I love what Rodney did!!
TechnoMistress
2008-11-27 . chapter 5
Hehe. I'm in so much trouble at work, 'cause they're all wondering why I was giggling incontrollably. Can't really tell them that it's the image of Sheppard's head in flames, now, can I?

Great story - this is the third time I've read it (needed a lift today). I like the way you've captured a different side of McKay, and I love the scene in the cafeteria with Ford.
sentarla
2008-04-18 . chapter 5
loved this story, rodney is so smart!
LinziDay
2007-11-08 . chapter 5
Very, very nice.
Dzerzhina
2007-10-14 . chapter 5
This is a really good story. I like how McKay juggles in it. Very funny!
b7-kerravon
2007-10-04 . chapter 5
This was wonderful - Rodney, cotton candy, juggling...what more could you ask?
Janchanb
2007-06-22 . chapter 5
^_^ Love the fic. I'm SO glad that my friend told me about this one! Though I'm kinda curious as to what John said to Rodney at the end of the fic to make Rodney do a double take.
spookysister7
2007-06-04 . chapter 5
aw. cute! i love your rodney.
Aloe
2007-01-19 . chapter 5
What a wonderful, happy story. I really enjoyed this, thanks for sharing. Yellow cotton candy ... *snickers*
SqueakyChewToy
2007-01-08 . chapter 5
WOW. That was really brilliant. I usually try to avoid holiday, and especially christmas themed fics, but boy am I glad I read this one cos I LOVED it. Thankyou.
Rhyska Nevar
2007-01-08 . chapter 5
That was awesome! Rodney rulz! This was definitely my favorite Atlantis Christmas story. I could totally see this happening and that's what I love about it. I look forward to more of your stories :D
Random Clone
2006-12-27 . chapter 4
POOR GRODIN!! Oh, the humiliation and embarrassment! *I* have been in his place before! Poor guy...

McKay juggles? Just like him to prove a point by doing something utterly surprising!

Merry Belated Christmas!
Hromiko
2006-12-27 . chapter 5
Wow, wonderful end to a wonderful story. :) I'm glad you addressed the oranges, I'd meant to question them last review but got distracted by other thoughts. The way he reacts to the sight of lemons makes me think he wouldn't even consider touching fruit that sat in a bowl with oranges (and one has to wonder how long oranges would've lasted anyway, by then they'd probably be eating mostly Pegasus fruit), but that's a minor quibble and you got to have a fun freakout afterward. :)

This was a well written, fun, happy Christmas story. When McKay was waking up here I was expecting something bad to happen (I always expect something bad to happen in fics of any length), but it was nice to have things just work out pleasantly. I think the other Christmas stories I've been reading have been a bit down, and I suppose the way people were treating McKay was a little depressing, but mostly it seemed happy, a nice look at how Christmas may've been trapped in another galaxy. Minor issue: where'd he get the holograph balls? If they've been in the show or other stories of yours, I don't recall, but personally I'm curious about where they came from all of the sudden. Oh! Other question: Whatever happened with the choir and other Atlantis music stuff? It's not the same to read about singing as actually hearing it so I can understand not writing it out or whatever, but I'm still curious about the other cultural exchange acts. Who are the Ratheans? I probably just forgot them from earlier in the story or something. Okay, I'm going to stop over analyzing and go back to just enjoying happy Christmas story goodness. :) Keep on writing!
Return to Top