Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Lady of the Gate - Page 1 of 8
TZMaverick 6/22/11 . chapter 19
Ah... I would love to see Jac in Atlantis.
bourbon92 6/8/11 . chapter 19
i just had to sign in and leave a review. i normally do not read any genderbender for the same reasons you don't, but after reading some of the reviews for your story i decided to give it a try... i gotta say i am very happy i did. this was a very well written and thought out story that i thoroughly enjoyed. i hope you continue to update your other stories. as soon as i click the submit button on the bottom of this pop up box i will be navigating to start on your next fan fic.
DammitJim 6/1/11 . chapter 19
Great fic!
alokin 2/12/11 . chapter 1
Dear God !

Jack ONeill gender bender ?

What an ABOMINATION !

I dont care even if its some insignificant character like Siler turned into a woman , Its just wrooong ...

And why did it have to be Jack ?

Why not Carter ?

To this date I HAVE YET TO SEE A GENDERBENDER WHERE THE WOMAN TURNS INTO A MAN ?
PatriciaS 12/28/10 . chapter 19
Nice round up to a great story and your notes were interesting as well. Glad you didn't go for anything but keeping Jac as Jac, Sam's attituded and their talk about their relationship felt right. Sending Jac to Atlantis is an intriguing idea, as for a sequal concerning SGA, (which I've not watched)you could either bring her back to earth and be teamed up her old team or send them over to Atlantis ... her team find something Daniel and Sam's experties is needed and break away from the tv series arc of stories.

Thanks for taking the time and sharing the story.
The DCG 12/24/10 . chapter 19
If your going to bother with the Atlantis at all i do hope you toss the cannon plot out the window. It's mind breakingly bad.

And really, jac's accident gean makes every else's go hide in the corner.

"she is simply a Captain and no one there knows her past."

Thats a rather piss poor excuse as most of the show is based on some chump who used to be only a chooper pilot. Only reason people follow him is becaus his dna makes things run(and bad writers). See above point for how jac would effect stuff.

that said more of jac would rock, your a very good writing no mater what way you take it.

I do hope Sam's wishy washy attitude comes back to bite her on the ass at lest..

I really don't want to comment more on the Alatans plot as i would be here for pages.. but come on its SPACE VAMPIRES. Im not sure weather jac would beat her head on the wall. Or gleefully perg that galaxy of them.
DarkRubberNeck 10/16/10 . chapter 17
*cries* Why, oh why have you not updated this awesomeness fic yet. I love this fic a tons and yet it looks like you stopped *cries some more*
anthropomorphizer 6/21/10 . chapter 17
An excellent story - you took a much deeper look at O'Neill's character than any other story I've ever read. Keep up the great work!
The DCG 5/7/10 . chapter 17
Wow, a hell of a fic here. And "jac" just makes it better. It's going to be interesting to see how you have her handle the future plot lines where things stack to ek out into a massive tech race.
DammitJim 5/4/10 . chapter 17
fantastic story! I look forward to reading more :)
sgo 4/3/10 . chapter 17
You said that you are close to the end, Please don't give up on this story. Although I cringe at the thought of Jack being a woman I think you have done a fantastic job with this story. Jac is Jack no matter what happens to him. You have done an amazing job with the characters and I can't wait to see where you are leading us.
imokit 10/15/09 . chapter 17
Good story!
Vampyre Moon 9/7/09 . chapter 17
i dont know if you meant it to be but this is a depressing, down sort of break
Bixata 5/23/09 . chapter 17
Great chapter! As always, I love the interaction between L'masee and Jac, and this was some very difficult issues they had to deal with, concerning Jac's future with SG-1. The humor is great, it so fits with the characters and the overall feel of the show. Really, really great story, thanks so much for the update.
Serran 5/20/09 . chapter 2
Okay, I just read the first two chapters and skimmed the reviews. I thought what I was about to write had been writen dozens of times already and I would just chew through things again. But I found no mention of it.

First the only thing that I am going to repeat from other, it is a pretty good story, even if I am not sure that I will read all of it.

Now to my nitpick and the plottholes I observed, I try to keep it relatively close to the succesion of events.

How did they hide that the female Jack never left Earth? And only came back with SG 5?

While a lot of the evidence can be destroyed any unsheldued offworld activation has armed personal swarming in the Gateroom, not to mention that the window is permanently manned.

Daniel, who got before his peers and basiclly said: "Everything you ever thought you knew about the Pyramids is wrong, here is the evidence." Is not a follower, he follows Jack's lead because that is what he signed up to do to rescue his wife and he understands that he is not the person to ask when it concerns looking at things from a military angle.

Another example represent the first contact with the tollan.

He srcewed over the military brass by helping them pretty badly.

The worst part to date however is the decision regarding the female O'Neill by the Pentagon, apparently against the explicit wishes of the President.

The President is the CiC 'Commander in Chief' the Big Cheese, the Head Honcho. However you want to call it, the Pentagon and its Generals are there to coordinate and command the armed forces.

The President commands the Pentagon.

And that is the crux of the matter, if Hayes disagrees with what they want to do to O'Neill then they (wohever they are, you mention no names, maybe becaue they did not apper in the show or you want to have them as mysterious, threatening presence in the background) then they are going to follow orders. At least if they want to retain their place in the Pentagon. I do not doubt there is a lot of politicing going on there. That does not mean I believe they would or could put presure on the President to cave in such a matter.

Whatever beef they have with O'Neill, he saved this world, more then once. He defied standing Orders that go to, or nearly to the top of the military command structure to do this the first time. (Apophis two Hatak's on the way to earth) There were no repercusions and Carter was even promoted because the alternative was far to bad to even contemplate.

Another point: Hammond is Chief of Homeworld security which reports directly to the President and the IOA. And no one else.

The IOA and every of it's member nations would have kittens if the SGC and it's technology was at the disposal of the entire United States armed forces. Not to mention what they are going to have to say about this situation.

Because when the military get's politically the Politicans will also want to get their say. And the entire SGC is only still an American military base because of O'Neill.

Not to mention the fact that the only reason why there is still a Pentagon is SG-1 under O'Neill.

Regarding the demotion: If "they" erased O'Neill's comission then they have no hold over her.

And they can not simple create a new one with the new identity. Because not only does this needs Paperwork, where Jacqeline would have to sign everything again, they need her cooperation.

There are laws in place that they can not simply ignore, and one of them is the right to choose.

Because the American military is build around the fact that you sign up for duty. What are they going to do if she does not play ball? Kill her? Imprision her?

The military is sworn in to uphold the constitution, unless they use Jack's old comission, and come up with a very good and very plausible answer for a military tribunal for stripping a Brigardier General of his rank and demoting him by four ranks every military personal in the know is practically obligated to stop them.

Security clearence: Season two, during the time when the NID was using the Antarctica Gate to go offworld illegaly. It was outright stated that SG1 had the highest military clearence in the States.

There are no blacked out military files for them. Period.

Considering everything that SG1 and Jack O'Neill in particular has done for earth I doubt any of 'them' would try to stick it to O'Neill that overtly or even covertly. Because when it comes right down to it they are more expendable for earth then O'Neill is. In Continuum Jack is still a Colonel, while in the Original timeline he is a Major General at this point plainly because they needed him there that much that his quirks could be overlocked.

So Rant mode of. This was just something that I had to put here. I know that half the ngst would vanish out of this fic if you integrated even one of these facts, but I was never one for angst and it took a lot for me to even start reading this fic. And it is written very good.
109 found: Page 1 2 3 4 .. 8 Next »
Return to Top