 apprenticeassassin 2008-11-18 . chapter 5Hey, great story. And as I read the same authors you do (whitehound, cecelle, etc.) don't go thinking I'm just saying that. the OCs so far are quite believable so far, and your premise seems interesting. So. were you planning to continue this?
And just as a side note: have you intentionally blocked anonymous reviews? |
 k.L.r 2007-07-23 . chapter 5Wow! This is a fantastic story. The elves are a really nice thing to put into the story.
Yeah, not much of a helpful review, but I just wanted to tell you that, in my opinion, you're doing a great job. |
 excessivelyperky 2007-07-21 . chapter 5I've read DH, and despite his treatment here, at least he has a chance (I hope). In DH, it looked like "it was time to do..." without any real reason dramatically, as far as I can tell. PPM me for more.
Good chapter, and I'm glad Snape has these house elves--he surely would have died of neglect and abuse otherwise. |
 whitehound 2007-07-21 . chapter 5Keep writing :) |
 duj 2007-07-21 . chapter 5What's wrong with Harry? |
 The Fluffy Ball of Doom 2007-07-20 . chapter 5Interesting to write it from the house elves' point of view. Your view of their psychology is interesting and seemingly accurate. I can't wait for the next chapter.
I also can't wait for tomorrow :p. |
 The Fluffy Ball of Doom 2007-07-19 . chapter 4All the extra stuff you've added (Lily angel in the beginning, the last scene in this chapter) are a little annoying, but well done story nonetheless. Keep it coming, please. |
 tpel 2007-07-05 . chapter 4I like this story a lot! Harry is acting like a prat, but with all he's been through that's understandable. I love Remus' determination to be a friend to Snape, albeit belatedly. The prospect of this Charity Wilson character is making me a bit nervous, as the build up for her is threatening to drift into Mary Sue territory. I'm starting to fear that you'll dwell on her role in Snape's recovery rather than the far more interesting roles of established characters, or worse, that you'll put her into a wholly-innapropriate-given-his-mental-state relationship with Snape. But that might just be my paranoia. After all, you did a great job with the little Ravenclaw lawyer, Sizemore, so I know you can do original characters well. Keep up the good work! |
 TwistedLilBarbie 2007-07-04 . chapter 3Really good fic, it has definitely intrigued me |
 excessivelyperky 2007-07-04 . chapter 4Of course Remus will be a good friend--till something really happens, and then he'll look the other way. Oh, he feels bad _now_. I bet he felt bad, before, too. Didn't keep him from standing by, either.
As for that village, one wonders if Dawlish doesn't spend the 'inspection' time in a brisk round of torture.
And Hermione on the warpath. Wonder if she'll manage to organize all the house elves? If that didn't bring the Ministry down, nothing would.
I think we can all imagine the sort of deal Scrimgeour made with Harry, though.
Good chapter--glad to see you back! |
 risi 2007-04-21 . chapter 3I think Hector's won his case, at least I hope so. I hope Rufus realizes it would be better for him to back off of further prosecution of Snape, at least if he wants to stay on the good side of the public. Harry should feel ashamed of himself. Can't wait for your next chapter. |
 duj 2007-04-10 . chapter 3If you want something done, do it yourself. |
 duj 2007-04-10 . chapter 2What took him so long? |
 duj 2007-04-10 . chapter 1A fate that many of us fear awaits our hero. |
 excessivelyperky 2007-04-09 . chapter 3Excellent chapter, and I hope you update soon. As for Phantom phanfic, I have a reference to _Phantom_ in my Beauty and the Beast story, "Persephone" (pimp, pimp, pimpetty pimp tra la). There are certain parallels there, as well.
Anyway, I can only guess that Rufus is somehow going to railroad Snape despite the memories, but I hope you manage to help him escape anyway. |