 Minerva's Daughter232 7/31/11 . chapter 1Yeah! Go McGonagall! Take that Slytherin!
sorry, I'm a bit of a Harry Potter fan. |
 Chemistress 3/17/08 . chapter 1:-) This is the first story I have read, where Minerva wins an argument with Snape just like that. Very nice! |
 serpentilewitch 7/29/05 . chapter 1Heh, brilliant! I dunno if Snape would let enough emotions surpass him to the point where he'd curse at a colleage to their face or even their near back, lol, but entertaining all the same. He makes quite a few valid points, too. P |
 RoseBookends 9/16/03 . chapter 1A.
The angst, the angst, the thrill. (For us.)
Marina, you rock.
rb |
 LinZE 4/16/03 . chapter 1Was there ever any doubt she would *smile*
I feel a lot of repressed sexual tension in this though. lol |
 SR1918 2/20/03 . chapter 1Great story. I really like the interaction between Snape and McGonagall, especially when she wins because he is still aborbed by the past and his own demons. |
 Glasen Dauthi 11/28/02 . chapter 1hehe, great little conversation. I'm glad that you managed for them to still be in character while arguing. And there seems to be another story around HP too |
 LOTRlover 8/31/02 . chapter 1Nice verbal duel! I think you caught their characters very well, and your prose flows beautifully. Well done. |
 Lady Cheshire 8/24/02 . chapter 1Aw, hell yeah! McGonnagall RULES!
Suberb job, everyone was fantastically in character. Well done! |
 Kate Matthews 8/21/02 . chapter 1 This is really good - I liked the way you stayed true to the characters and matched the language to that used in the books rather than throwing in loads of Americanisms. I'd love to see more of this - perhaps a tale of when they first met, and how this animosity came about? |
 Jane Fairfax 8/7/02 . chapter 1Go McGonnagal! YAAAAAYYYYYY! |
 Tricia1 7/13/02 . chapter 1eheeheehee, way to go, Minnie! _ |
 Ariana Deralte 6/5/02 . chapter 1Hilarious and well written. Very in character too IMO. Well done:) |
 eosphorosa 5/23/02 . chapter 1Even though I'm in love with Severus Snape, I am glad to see that he has finally been shown that he is not the only person with a quick wit and sharp tongue. This is magnificent! :D |
 PiperX 4/27/02 . chapter 1Hee hee - that was great! I love the house rivalry between these two. Mcgonagall & Snape are two of the coolest characters in the books and you can tell that they are very competitive with each other. I'd love to read more like this! |