| Reviews for Astronomer: Past and Present |
|---|
hajimebassaidai 5/4/10 . chapter 1That is beautiful. One, I've discovered a new poem that says something to me. Second I love the three time periods in this story. The first shows John quietly hiding his intelligence and deliberately maintaining his wonder at the stars, leaving the lecture to keep it uncrushed. Then he shows Rodney his place to view the stars and while Rodney doesn't see the pure joy of it, his innate curiosity and constant quest for understanding means that his intellectual approach doesn't damage John's experience but enhances it. Then finally, after what he experienced Rodney gets it and the two od them share the wonder of it all. Loved it! |
Whirlwind421 4/1/08 . chapter 1I love it! I love John too! Great story! |
heartfallen 11/20/07 . chapter 1awesome story! |
Lilith Lunatic 5/31/07 . chapter 1Lovely. I've always had a thing about the stars, too, so this story is particularly touching. |
Harm Marie 5/22/07 . chapter 1This is a great poem and I loved your story interpretation of it. |
laurelisland 2/26/07 . chapter 1This was wonderful. The poem fit the story so well (and the other way around :) ). Nice to see that Rodney has a certain latitude not usually seen in scientists and why John's not too fond of science himself. Thank you. |
Lady Lemons 1/22/07 . chapter 1aw cute! I liked the pov too! Kudos! |
Cap10 1/22/07 . chapter 1Another good story. Keep posting. |
scifi lemon 1/22/07 . chapter 1love it! very touching and well writen. |