Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Most Important Element in Water - Page 1 of 13
HarryPotterFanaticToTheEnd
2009-11-01 . chapter 23
This is very well done. Please update.
Tribblelet
2009-08-05 . chapter 23
very nice, very nice.
Firestormpwr
2009-08-04 . chapter 23
well i geuss i hadnt reviewed this chapter yet hmm wonder why? anywho after rereading it again when are you going to post part three? been a few months now :D
astig01
2009-07-04 . chapter 23
well, after thinking about this story I decided to re-read it... I luv this story as it is different from most out there. I am looking forward to Part 3 I hope you are enjoying your break. astig
Inner Self
2009-05-25 . chapter 23
so it isn't over? hm. interesting.
Inner Self
2009-05-25 . chapter 22
wow. ive never seen ron act so cool. i might even start reading fanfictions on him!
Inner Self
2009-05-24 . chapter 15
severus almost suceeded in his imitation of kyle reese. i feel so sorry for parvati. if only hermione had subdued then earlier.
Inner Self
2009-05-24 . chapter 12
Did you get the idea for the curse on Dumbledore from ALS? I luv this story. thankyou.

ps. why does this story have less than 200 reviews? or better yet, why less than 10?
Inner Self
2009-05-24 . chapter 10
::mixed emotions:: is there any deceptive spell snape could be using? he's killing too many people! my confidence in him is lost! this is worse than book 6 or 7! great! just great; hermione's the dead woman. or can she be the man on fire? she did burst into ashes.
excessivelyperky
2009-02-27 . chapter 23
Yay, Crooks! Brilliant chapter, great battle, amusing coda. I'm glad all the Horcruxes are gone, and sorrow that Tom was destroyed too soon. That was neat about Peter helping Remus, though--Marauders stick together to the end.

Yay!
Allison
2009-02-20 . chapter 23
Wow, i can now officially breathe again after finishing that chapter. That was intense and amazing!!
snakegirl-sprockett
2009-02-20 . chapter 23
oh!

I hope sev n Herm are ok, but am glad that crookshanks came and helped! :D:D:D

I'm glad voldy is dead, tho am sad that ratty made neville do it.

Looking forward to the next chapter!!
xx
Dhelana Joie
2009-02-15 . chapter 23
WOW!
Amazing so far, I'm looking forward to Part 3.


The only thing I've had a problem with thus far was Harry's attitude towards the beginning. I felt it was rather out of canon, unless that's what you meant to do.
But besides that, well written. :)
mlle Lola D.
2009-02-13 . chapter 23
Go Crooks! Really, the whole chapter was incredible, but you crammed so much story into that epilogue, and all from a cat's perspective. That's talent.
sylphides
2009-02-13 . chapter 23
I was completely enthralled by this chapter! It was beautiful, lyrical, and gritty. The threads you've been weaving with Sun Tzu and the rest of the story came together harmoniously in the most ingenious way I've ever seen to become magical and be the demise of Voldemort. The epilogue in the pov of Crookshanks is quizzical and unexpected, but also very telling and original. Together, the philosophy and the action came together in your writing to create a chapter- and and story- that is equally thought-provoking and sense-gripping. I can't wait for part 3!!
Return to Top