Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Black Comedy - Page 1 of 261
A-Writer-Bro
2009-11-24 . chapter 7
Brilliant.
Obamarocks2008
2009-11-21 . chapter 1
bice
Avy-Snape
2009-11-19 . chapter 31
hi
now i've just finished your story and i think it's completely amazing! as far as i have delved into ff reading, this story is actually one that doesn't rewrite old plotlines over and over and that's what really captured my interest in this story. what kept me all 31 chapters though was that while harry was powerfull, he kept it in bounds and therefore was just coolness impersonated and i just loved the funniness of the whole fic. (i love those repeating things that just gives the whole fic a hint of absurdness that's very captivating).
I really enjoyed reading this, thanks for that opportunity! =)

Avy
gauravmittal2
2009-11-15 . chapter 31
b
gauravmittal2
2009-11-14 . chapter 10
very very nice
Saberus9
2009-11-12 . chapter 31
This story was in a word: Brilliant!
I loved the whole thing and i had no clue who 'That Fucker' was until you revealed it.
My hat off to you, good sir, on making a magnificent masterpiece.
BrightMikal
2009-11-07 . chapter 4
I love Ghost Ginny! 'Love Shield!' *cracks up laughing* She's my favourite character in this fic, I believe.
BrightMikal
2009-11-07 . chapter 20
The Hermione in this scene is ridiculously funny! The nuudu, the fact she's drunk on butterbeer, and everything is great comedy! Keep writing!
BrightMikal
2009-11-07 . chapter 31
I loved this fic! It was so funny, I couldn't stop laughing in some chapters. Your characters, your plot, and your Sirius/Harry relationship were amazing. I loved the idea of Ghost Ginny, that Harry constantly screws people around, and more. The only thing I think should have happened was that Ghost Ginny got her wishes, at least once! Great bit of writing, loved it!
Molto Alesato
2009-11-05 . chapter 28
You really need to make a shot about the Potters reactions tho the pensive memories!
Kalthurin
2009-11-05 . chapter 31
i can honestly say my friend, that you have one funky ass way of taking something in a whole new direction.

i loved it although i will say you did something authors very rarely do to me, made me sad it finished.

but on a more critque esq note i think a second installment would be a good thing showing the developement between riddlebottom-harry-albus and their eventuall shifts in power status and the whole hinted idea of harry being the hogwarts headmaster aswell as the head warlock.

also where sirius would be lead when harry was no longer such a majour player in his life, i myself would easily see him being a legit treasure hunter and thrill seaker/adrenalin junkie a bit like that dude out the third book who gets smaked by his own memory charm, the (magical me) writer i can never remember his name for which i appologise crossed with indianna jones and subsequently take on sports like cranning parcur elevator surfing train surfing etc but then again thats more of me showing through than an evaluation of his character

but still kudos abound dude that was one killer fic and i loved it shame it had to end though
Schermionie
2009-11-04 . chapter 31
Never been any good at reviewing completed multi-chapter stories, but I'd just like to say that I think you achieved your goal. Thanks for an amazing fanfiction -- well, 'amazing' doesn't do it justice really... perfect? Pretty much. It's rare that someone can get the blend of wry and crackish humour and a serious, complicated and intriguing plot right, but you did it with this fic. I'm glad I finally decided to read it, after maybe even a couple of years of thinking about it but not doing anything. My one criticism? That I still can't remember where "you can keep my sandwich" comes from. xD *Adds to favourites*
Silver Curse
2009-11-01 . chapter 31
It was awesome.
It was really funny, with a touch of insanity. I loved it.
I know you said it is 'unlikely' that you'd ever write a sequal, but could you at least write a oneshot? It's really that good.
Alicia Spinet
2009-10-29 . chapter 31
I derasay, this was the most hilarious fic that i read in here. I laugh the whole time. I really loved read this fic. By! By!
Httw
2009-10-28 . chapter 29
Can't smother my laughter much longer!! My roommates already think I'm crazy! XD
Return to Top