Perfect characterization. Great job.

I've always wanted to read a story about McGonagall "scolding" Harry for the "sectumsempra incident" :)

One word : perfect ! :p
Really nicelly done ;)

I hope you'll keep writing "missing moments"... you're really good at it ;)

Cheers !

I like this story. It's really cute!

Lovely story! I loved the way you went between James' talk with Minerva and Harry's talk... it was very well written!

Merciful Heavens

That's great, really! I love anything Marauder-era & I love McGonagall! I can't write McGonagall, but, hey, no one's perfect! This is really good! Nice work!

This is lovely.

I totally agree that James probably did something similar when he was in school, and whether he wants to admit it or not, Harry probably acts a whole lot like his father.

A great idea!

How's World Enough and Time coming?

Well, that was really interesting. I really liked the comparisons with Harry's father - from the summary I'd kind've expected to be reading comparisons with Sirius after the whole leading-Snape-to-a-werewolf incident. But this was great! Only I wasn't sure if your point was that Harry really was very similar to James, or if you were trying to show the way the other characters, namely McGonagall, failed to see how different Harry was from James.

Still, I loved it! McGonagall is probably my favourite HP character (or maybe I just love Maggie Smith) so I love reading anything about her.

i like this fic. thanks!

Great chpater. Yeah, it's quite strange to see how much similar and at the main time different are Harry andJames ^-^

Beautiful! Purely beautiful.

Hey! I really enjoyed this, there's some great insights into Harry, James and not least McGonagall. A wonderful idea, executed beautifully. It never really hit me just how frightening it must be for teachers like McGonagall to have to face another James Potter. And although seeing everything through Harry's eyes in the books makes it seem like there's more of a difference between them, your story shows just how alike father and son really are. Well done, lovely work!

I loved this one-shot; it was excellent.

The exploration of the parallels between Harry and James were done in a curiously fascinating manner.

Minerva's feelings towards both of them are appropriate and well-written. Keep up the good work!

I liked this piece a lot. I hope that you keep writing.

Very good writing.
I'm deeply disappointed that Harry didn't put the bleached ponce out of misery in HBP.
Well there might still be a chance in the Deathly Hallows.

Great Job!! Love the idea! really original!!

keep writing