Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: My Deadly Little Secret - Reviews: Page 1 of 3

darkelf1600
2008-06-20
ch 1,
abuseyou know, I really liked this. It's a great idea and you pulled it of well. I can't wait to read more
Thunder-Kun
2008-05-27
ch 1,
abuseOh, two of my favorite shows smashed together sounds amazing! I say go for it, and I can't wait to see what you come up with.
Cassandra Pierson
2008-05-25
ch 1,
abuseI haven't read a lot of Dead Like Me or Scrubs fanfics up to now, but I enjoyed this one very, very much.
Owl Emporium
2008-04-18
ch 1,
abuseYou know that was actually quite interesting...oh my god, how cool would that be? And stupid bastard...anyways, great job! I loved it. I never would've thought JD as that...interesting idea. :) Ha, he showed Dr Cox, didn't he? Anyways, good job. :)

Angelica
Draw4life
2008-04-05
ch 1, anon.
abuseI love your writing style! I actually read "SoCalled Afterlife" first, and what you have up of the sequal, and I had to see what else you had written for the category! i know nothing of 'dead like me', but i can still follow your story and still understand it completely! I think thats a very good trait in story writing, to be able to combine stories (like you did) and still be able to have your readers understand what is happening without knowing one of the original stories is VERY COOL. I will try to keep up with the sequal of SoCalled Afterlife (which I must say that I love that you made Cox a reaper!), but I may not be able to because I'm only on here every so often, and even then not that much.

I also liked hearing exactly what happened to Jack Castello after reading about his post reactions in SoCalled AFterlife. VERY COOL.

Anyway, keep writing!
-Draw4life
qwerty
2008-03-11
ch 1,
abusedude this is great I carn't belive I haven't read this before your rule.
Witty-Kate
2008-03-05
ch 1,
abuseomg so that was the referance in your my so called afterlife! now that was good! cant beleave i havnt read this beofre... and now i want to know all about dead like me even MORE than before...
jamestheeight
2008-01-26
ch 1,
abuseThis is really good! I've read half of the 2nd story And there both amazin!
Rebell
2007-11-30
ch 1,
abuseCool! I haven't seen Dead Like Me (I don't even know what channel it comes on... {grins sheepishly}) but I liked the idea of JD being a reaper so much I had to check this out.

Needless to say, it's pretty darn awesome!

Off to check out the others!
gravitation gig
2007-10-12
ch 1, anon.
abusei love you~~ this is a brilient cross over~ i just read your other fic sequel to this but it is a nice way to start up a fic~~
i wonder if janitor knows...
.
2007-08-05
ch 1, anon.
abuseAbsolutely amazing story!! I love stories where JD shows he's got a spine and he acts all tough. Great story.
tcg/animefan
2007-06-18
ch 1,
abuseYou have a good idea here, even if your grammar's a bit off. Mostly little details a thorough proof-read would've caught.

The jokes were good, but not great. You missed the minor details that make them funny, like Dr. Kelso's perfectly straight face, or other gestures and expressions the characters constantly use.

Speaking of Dr. Kelso, you downplayed his humanity a bit much in this. While he is a "Ba$ta*d coated ba$ta*d with ba$ta*d filling, there has been evidence that he still posses a shred of human compassion in his body.

Also, you seldom described the setting and positioning of the characters, making the scenes difficult for the reader to get a good picture of.

You also broke the "show don't tell" rule, making the way you introduced the idea of JD being a reaper seem a bit random. I know you were going for shock and awe value, but you got that just fine by having JD act so intense, not by randomly assigning him powers. What you could have done was show him performing a reap, perhaps introducing some of his associates in the reaping world.

Note that this is not to say that I did not like your story. I did. It was good, but every writer has room for improvement. Except Herbie Brennan, the awesome, British author of the Farie Wars Chronicles. Yes, I know that "awesome British" is redundant.

But seriously, I look forward to reading any upcoming stories in this series. You did good. Maybe not great, but upper-level good. 7.5/10.
RosaLev
2007-05-24
ch 1,
abuselove it so much i can't deal.
sausuge
2007-05-12
ch 1,
abuseah, now it makes more since... guess i should have read this one first... :)

i really like this little series you've got goin' so far! its intrueguing, and addicting. i've never seen the show 'dead like me' before, but i suddenly have the urge to watch it! :)

please update my so-called afterlife soon!
cassiopoeia_au
2007-03-28
ch 1, anon.
abuseThis is so awesome! I was so hooked right to the end, and I know it was a one-shot, but it makes you think about what happens next, and what the Janitor knows - it's really well written. Like to read more of your stuff : )
Return to Top