ok, so im confused cause i read alot of stories, did ravenstar met a book in another book, or am i confusing stories, plz tell me!!

pf lunapaw went 2 shadowclan for sure, awesome story keep it up!!

3 things

1.leafpaw is funny and awesome
2.it may not matter, but it was a wild rabbit with dirt on its claws that infected longtail's eyes, preventing him from seeing.
3.this story is the best!

1 word to describe blackclaw: bitch haha great job!

I Love this series... and there have been male medicine cats in Thunderclan... Featherwhisker and Goosefeather... Featherwhisker was Spottedleaf's mentor and Goosefeather was Featherwhisker's mentor... Goosefeather went crazy

I like the idea of Nightheart for Nightpaw and Shadowfang for Shadowpaw

I like Lunaheart for Lunapaw. It suits Ravenstar and Hawktar's second daughter a lot. Hope u like the name.

longtails eyes got scratched by a rabbit read Firestars Quest

Thoroughly freaked now!! Surveillance came back as Ravenstar...that is the weirdest twist yet!
~iDG

I love leafpaw!! She's adorable...and chatty...Like me!! lol
~iDG

My second time reading the series...I thought Huntingkit was alive! Wasn't he the one who fell in love with Nightpaw as a kit, but then broke her heart for Seashore?
--Cloudy

perhaps i was wrong...i guess hunter was some kind of red herring for the story...i was glad that shadowpaw lived! good ending! but twolegs are doing something now...something scary...i'll read on in burning moon! good job!

nasty nasty nasty cliffie! though i think i know who surveillance sees...HUNTER! i knew that he would come back. trust me, i didn't read the next chapter, i promise! i just knew, ok?...

YES! yay shadowpaw! now shadowpaw is my favorite character!

now both ravenstar's daugthers are dead! WAH! so sad. lunapaw will always have a place in my heart...